Coney McKane's American Eatery

Category: American restaurant in Decatur, Illinois

Address: 104 E Prairie Ave, Decatur, IL 62523, USA

Phone: +12174751111

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 11AM–7:30PM

Wednesday: 11AM–7:30PM

Thursday: 11AM–7:30PM

Friday: 11AM–8PM

Saturday: 11AM–8PM

Reviews

VVeMoveForward

May 24, 2022

Our server James was incredible. Seriously, no BS, this man rendered surely the BEST service I've had all year. And it's definitely in the top 3 for all time. We were a 6top and our drinks/beer was always full. He took our order with no notepad, and everything came out absolutely perfect. And we had complicated orders! Super fun and friendly. Consistently checked in with us to make sure everything was good to go! The food was good, definitely. But James exceptional service will be the #1 reason I come back.

Azra Hostetler

Mar 5, 2022

I liked it. I had half a sandwich and a soup with chips. I also had dessert, but it was too much for one person; I would only get it if I was sharing. I want to try it again. Wasn't a fan of their chips (a little too salty).I would love to try their salads. Also, the beer I was served wasn't very cold in the bottle. Nice place, seems very busy.

Rosie Gibbons

Mar 1, 2022

Wonderful food, great pie,and cute cookies. We took our sister out for a birthday lunch. Waiter was superb- fast and efficient and fun. I ordered the soup and salad combo so I would have room for the dessert. Fresh chicken salad, cheesey french onion soup topped with homemade cherry pie. Yummy!

Bill Kindred

Oct 28, 2021

Everything was Absolutely Amazingly Delicious. The Bloodys were on point, the Southwest Chicken Rolls had Amazing flavor, the Buff-ickory Chicken was Killer and the French Dip was packed full of flavor. I highly recommend this place!!! check it out not one complaint here at all great great service, the food was amazing and the atmosphere here was chill and laid-back.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Can you place orders for a whole pie and pick up?

Majestic Empire | May 13, 2019
Jerry Davis | May 14, 2019

Yes

Read More

Hope you maintain the outdoor service each summer, it was nice sitting out and having lunch with friends!

Evyonne Hawkins | Jul 16, 2020
Shawn | Jul 17, 2020

Yes I agree

Is it handicap accessible? Did u have pic of exterior?

Vera Franklin | May 13, 2019
Rachel McCarthy | May 14, 2019

Yes, it is handicap accessible on the cross street of East Prairie. Handicap entrance on East Prairie. The door will be locked, but they will see you and unlock the door per the restaurant. I don't have a picture, but it is street level, and with highly visible windows. Free street and parking lot parking on on Main Street. Make sure you leave room for a slice of pie.

Read More

Can you accommodate a party of 5 outside on 8/17 around 1 pm?

Kelli Iversen | Sep 14, 2020
Sonya Anthony | Sep 15, 2020

They sure should be able to. Call them to make a reservation.

What varieties are available?

Ruth Hilvety | May 12, 2020
karl Mack | May 13, 2020

They have a lot of different stuff very nice I love this place.

Read More

Do you take reservations for Fri. evening?

john golden | May 12, 2020
Matthew Holman | May 13, 2020

Coney Mckane's doesn't take reservations or call-aheads. It is first come, first serve. In addition, your entire party must be present before you'll be seated.

Do you deliver? If so, how far will you go. I live in the West End. Thank you

Moviegal60 | May 13, 2019
MK Johannes | May 14, 2019

I think they just deliver downtown for lunch.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places