Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Upper West Side

Category: Italian restaurant in New York

Address: 2450 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, USA

Phone: +12123622200

Opening hours

Sunday: 11:30AM–10PM

Monday: 11:30AM–10PM

Tuesday: 11:30AM–10PM

Wednesday: 11:30AM–10PM

Thursday: 11:30AM–10PM

Friday: 11:30AM–11PM

Saturday: 11:30AM–11PM


Allison Richardson

Nov 7, 2022

My experience there was horrible . The wait was ridiculous though I had reservations for two. My reservation was for 6:45 to be seated inside, instead we ended up outside. The server was rude and acted as if though he didn't want to serve my table. They were more willing to serve the marathon runners than the regular patrons. The service was just the worst for all the money charged for two simple dishes. A bowl of rigatoni pasta with sausage that was non existent and a salmon oreganata. I was also forced to order extra sausage for the pasta dish. The sausage was brought to the table uncut just plopped down on the table as if though we were bothering the server. A lemonade was the only other item that we had at the table. The dinner I waited for came to a cool $150.00 . I left a tip of $40 though in my mind nothing should have been left. I'm bigger than that and decided to behave as such. I Definitely did not enjoy my meal and remain annoyed by the poor service. A reservation for 6:45 pm and not seated until 7:30 pm and that was due to me having to assert myself so that they would seat my guest and I. They overbooked and instead of telling patrons that they had parties of anything less than four wait while they continuously seated parties of 5- 10 people. A really bad taste left in my mouth the server the hostess need to definitely be replaced. Dinner outing was the nightmare from hell.

Montana Lewis

Nov 7, 2022

Always love the food. However, I ordered a glass of wine and they served it in this super tiny cup that they use for water and charged $15. Kind of surprised they don’t carry wine glasses so you can get an amount of wine in the cup that is worth the money.

Ishaan Sang

Nov 6, 2022

Didn’t like the food here. Not sure why it has such a higher rating.


Nov 5, 2022

Great restaurant and this place leaves the tourist spot near Times Square. The dish comfortably serves two people, I ordered the Spaghetti a Pomodoro, well seasoned (garlic in measure). Very good service, authentic Italian food restaurant in NY.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they have parking??

Sancia | Nov 8, 2019
Christina Woods | Nov 8, 2019

Metered Street Parking only.

Read More

Parking at carmine's

Darryl Harris | Nov 8, 2017
BlairWitch-The Sorceress | Nov 8, 2017

No, they don't have

Read More

do they open on christmas eve or christmas day?

Timothy Yi (timothy) | Oct 8, 2022
Trevor Bonner | Oct 8, 2022

Can't confirm or deny. Call to verify.

Read More

Is rack of lamb on the menu and what is the cost

Pam McD | Jul 10, 2022
Mark Henderson | Jul 10, 2022

Yes and nice and tender

Is there parking garges near by

Marc Callahan | Jan 11, 2022
John Cardin | Jan 11, 2022

There's street parking. It can be a bit difficult to find a spot, so make sure you give yourself enough time incase you have a reservation.

Are Texans welcomed?

Slim Pickens | Dec 12, 2021
Kevy. B | Dec 12, 2021

Yes, As long as you have your Covid vaccination card if you want to dine inside.

Read More


Anonymous | Nov 7, 2022
Anonymous | Nov 7, 2022


We have reservations in December for our annual family celebration. As of now no inside dining. Do you have any idea if that will change by December 19th or 20th ?

Stephen Rozzi | Nov 7, 2020
Sandra A | Nov 7, 2020

According to Cuomo, inside dining will resume on September 30th at 25% capacity. If all goes well, you should be fine by December. Do keep in contact with the restaurant for updates.

What credit cards does Carmines take

Lisa Stathas | Nov 7, 2020
Rosetta Gadson | Nov 7, 2020

All...Im Quite Certain..and Cash Is Queen Of Course!!

Read More

What is the dress code?

chris c | Nov 8, 2019
Jessica Rodriguez | Nov 8, 2019

Dress code is casual, comfy. Dress for your occasion.

Read More

can you call in for a pick up?

d calvin williams | Nov 8, 2019
Shaun Kerr | Nov 8, 2019

Yes you can

Read More

What subway is close

Jimmy S | Nov 8, 2019
Daniel Dambrosio | Nov 8, 2019

IRT #1 stop @ Broadway and 96th St.

Read More

What about take out

Joseph Darby | Nov 8, 2017
Amy Hollis | Nov 8, 2017

Yes they do takeout

Read More

Do you tke credit cards?

Marianne Barcellona | Aug 9, 2022
Kelly Moreno | Aug 9, 2022


Read More

Is the restaurant fully wheelchair accessible?

Jodi McLaren | Apr 11, 2022
Felicia Nicole Purvis | Apr 11, 2022

Only outside

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Nov 7, 2022
Stefanie Sanders | Nov 7, 2021

You must wear a mask, social distancing. Waiters have mask and gloves on. If eating in you must make a reservation in advance. You can order on your phone and get your food as a pickup or delivered to you. If you want delivery confirm first that they deliver to your area.

is there outside dining now? and is there a heater?

Eileen Carrera | Nov 7, 2021
brandon mack | Nov 7, 2021

Tents but no heaters as of yet

Read More

Hello my names is Gaby and I have been a costumer of Charmaine’s for many years and I love the the for the food so much is my favorite place. Yes I went to there but the pasta 🍝 it doesn’t take the same anymore. Have you chanothe recipe?

Gabriela Melgarejo | Nov 8, 2019
UFREAKINTOOL | Nov 8, 2019

Maybe a different chef that day?

do you guys deliver to W ashington nights?

Rashod Monroe | Nov 8, 2019
Frankie killgore | Nov 8, 2019

No too far try uber eats

You take reservations only?

bubah conteh | Nov 8, 2019
Dana Faria | Nov 8, 2019

No but there is usually a long wait with no reservations

Read More

Do you accept credit cards

Leonard Flocco | Nov 8, 2019
Juanita Robinson | Nov 8, 2019


Read More

Are they gluten free options?

June Hemstock | Nov 8, 2019
Beverly Coakley | Nov 8, 2019

Not sure, as far as I know the food is made from scratch and is fresh.

Are you open Christmas Day?

Jean DeQuinzio | Nov 8, 2019
Chris Diaz | Nov 8, 2019

You would have to call them

Do you do pizza please

Ben Abbott | Nov 8, 2019
Zully Soto | Nov 8, 2019

No pizza.exellent food and good ambient

Read More

Where can u park? Address with crossstreet?

Alc Cestaro | Nov 8, 2019
Steven Solomon | Nov 8, 2019

Many lots on the side streets. The one on W90th and Amsterdam has an arrangement for a lower price as I recall

Read More

Is there parking?

Manny Katz | Nov 8, 2018
Caleb Abbott | Nov 8, 2018


Read More

Is this an expensive place overall. Need to know going to a birthday dinner need to know how pricey the place is.

Charese D. LaCombe | Nov 8, 2018
Alethea Hendricks | Nov 8, 2018

Carmine is not expensive cause 1 order can actually feed three people

Read More

What is the price of a whole cheese cake, take out

Cheryl Shirley | Nov 8, 2018
Richie Rich | Nov 8, 2018

Italian cheesecake for 4 is $24.95.

Read More

Are you wheel chair accessseble??

erik walton | Nov 8, 2018
Richie Rich | Nov 8, 2018

Yes both locations in NYC are.

Read More

How far from radio city m u sic hall

Carole Canzoneri | Nov 8, 2018
Donna Williams | Nov 8, 2018

RCMH is on 6th Ave & 50th street and Carmine's is on Broadway between 90th & 91st streets. So about 2 miles. The M7 bus will take you up Amsterdam Ave. to 90th street. You can walk 1 block west to Broadway and Carmine's is right on B'way. Have fun, they serve family style so don't eat anything before going.

Read More

How far away are you from play bronx tales? West 48th street?

Jayne | Nov 8, 2017
Onika Bright | Nov 8, 2017

It's on 91st and Broadway.

Are the steak dinners expensive?

Victor Green | Nov 8, 2017
Becksguy | Nov 8, 2017

Yes, but it's an Italian-American restaurant, not a steakhouse pet se.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places