Coney Island Cafe

Category: American restaurant in Middletown, New York

Address: 10 Railroad Ave, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Phone: +18453433714

Opening hours

Sunday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Monday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Tuesday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Wednesday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Thursday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Friday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Saturday: 6:30AM–7:30PM

Reviews

Bruce Decker

Jul 9, 2022

Excellent Hadn't been there in years, stopped in for a couple Coney dogs Just like the old days and I mean the 1960s Good job Brings back good memories and I will be back

Jillian Oetzel

May 26, 2022

Staff is friendly. The food is delicious and the prices are very reasonable.

Charisha Jamison

Oct 5, 2021

Recently started job in area and was looking for a good breakfast sandwich. The sandwich was decent but I also ordered chicken soup and a salad for lunch. Lunch, no so good. Soup tasted like dirty water with an abundance of noodles. No chicken or veggies at all. They made the salad with big hunks of iceberg lettuce (which I hate) and there’s literally no seasoning on the chicken. Will go back if I had to for breakfast but that’s about it. The people were nice so that’s a plus.

Anna Xu

Jul 15, 2021

Recommended by a friend who has been living in Middletown for over 40 years, so we tried their loaded hotdogs. It was good, and I liked the fries too. Very good prices too. Would like to try their breakfast sometime.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Mar 5, 2021
Joann | Mar 6, 2021

mask social distantly

Why did Coney Island change their brand if hotdogs. They alwsys had the plump pinkish dog. Just went there and the dog was thin and red. No the same. I've been eating Coney's since the 70's. Not the same.

william springs | Nov 5, 2020
Joann | Nov 6, 2020

sorry really could not tell you have not had a hot dog there in years so sorry to hear that they always had the best hot dogs

Where can I find the lunch specials?

Lulu Matuszewski | May 5, 2019
rafeki Kirk | May 6, 2019

They have a Facebook page. Very good food

Can you mail us some famous coney sauce to florida? My dad will pay anything to have some shipped overnight!

Sarah Billings | May 5, 2018
Mary Wiltshire | May 6, 2018

You need to contact the store in Middletown. I just left a review when I was there this summer. Im in South Carolina.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places