Tisha's Fine Dining

Kevin Stepanuk

We are locals and haven't dined at Tisha's for dinner since early pandemic. This has been our loss. Our dinner was a totally enjoyable experience with a very friendly staff, professional service and delicious courses. The two tables next to us likewise enjoyed their experiences and meals and had ordered items different from ours. The clam chowder has always been terrific here and continues to be so. We likewise enjoyed the arancini. Some of the meals here come with heavy northern Italian type sauces but that was not the case with either our seafood risotto or the short rib ragu and pappardelle. The risotto had a wonderful broth and was full of seafood and mushrooms. The ragu was delicious as well. Nice warm rolls were served. This is a BYOB establishment so you can save by bringing your own libation, but they offer Cape May Winery wines (which are good!) at reasonable prices. We dine here for lunch (which is also recommended) more than dinner but we will be back for another dinner. Conveniently located on the Mall, this is worth trying.

Shannon Ruk

Really expensive for the quality of food. Everything was super dry. We had outdoor seating and I was freezing the whole time. Seeing we were outside, we rarely saw our waitress and it took forever to get the check.

William Schauer

Salad, arancini and scallops in sambucca sauce were all excellent. Best tasting food we've had this year. Ample portions and excellent service. Don't miss it.

Peggy Johnson

We are actually still sitting here finishing our meal( don’t hate me, I’m too satisfied to talk). First the special with the scallops was amazing and my husband had the chicken from the main menu. But honestly, one of our servers, Ben, recommended the clam chowder instead of the lobster bisque we were ordering for an appetizer and it was the best part of the meal. So amazing that we took some take out home with us for the next day’s dinner. The meal was outstanding in all ways. You cannot go wrong with Tishes