Gatsby's Pub & Grill

Tambra Macaluso

First visit....for Trivia Night!! We came in 5th, YAY US! I enjoyed the mushrooms and the BPT was very good. Thanks Erin for taking great care of a table of newbies (our table neighbors said we were virgins 😊).

Christie Campbell (A Kitchen Hoor)

We walked here from our hotel. It looks like a hole in the wall place to someone not from Indy. We were hungry and had few options. But let me tell you, the onion rings tasted JUST like you want them to taste. Super crispy on the outside and tender and sweet in the inside. The potato skins were full of cheese and crisp. But the fried mushrooms were THE BEST!! They batter them there. Not pre-frozen like some. They are so flavorful, crispy, and irresistible! Everything was delicious!!! And the beers were good too.

Darrion McAlister

I found this place from a Groupon I had bought, but never had heard of it before. For starters, my waitress was super nice. I missed the fine print on my Groupon that said “take out only” and she allowed me to use it with a dine-in purchase. Thank you so much for that, ma’am!! My friend and I went on a Friday and the best part was the karaoke they had going on. The atmosphere here was really enjoyable. I will definitely go back! Photo 1: Lamb Gyro and tots The sandwich was good for a gyro. I was expecting there to be a little more meat, but the flavor was definitely there. The tots were to my perfection - crispy but still fluffy. Photo 2: Hot wings The wings were decent - nothing spectacular. They were a little fatty and we were expecting them to be drenched in sauce. As you can see, it was just poured over. Photo 3: Poppers Their jalapeño poppers were delicious. My only recommendation would be maybe do 8 per basket instead of 6 as they’re fairly small. I’d highly recommend as an appetizer though!

Jenny Owens-Cripe

I always love stopping at Gatsby's! Sometimes it's just a beer sometimes we get dinner. They new (since covid) potato seating is fantastic on warm nights! But in October the Halloween decor is outstanding!!! Friendly staff & good food & drinks, also!