New York Pizza Company

Michael Ross

Sad to admit I was disappointed. Large pizza was size of a typical medium pizza. Crust was thin but cheese and toppings were lacking. Had high hopes as I was looking for a new go-to pizza shop near our new home. Second issue was cost. Paid over $45 for two pizzas that were undersized and did not meet expectations. Need to explore all options in a new area. Lesson learned.

Sherine Khaled

With all due respect, I would give half a star if I could. I ordered at 8pm after being put on hold for ten minutes and my cousin was hung up on. After ordering, I was told 4 items would take 60-70 minutes for pick up and delivery would be longer. After arriving at 8:50 I proceeded to wait after paying until 9 when the salad was made, and 9:30 when the two pasta dishes were made. I was told I would only have to wait for the garlic knots that came with the pastas. Once those were done, I had to wait another 15 minutes watching the chef do nothing while I was told I had to wait yet again for mozzarella sticks which were not made until 9:40. I left at 9:45 when I had first called at 7:50. When I got home with my order, the mozzarella sticks were soaked in the marinara. I understand things happen but when the chef is walking around doing nothing and the cashier has to make excuses for his laziness or for the fact that it took two hours to get my order and the workers were cleaning up to close around us. I’m sorry but that shouldn’t happen.

Jan Vickery

This is our "go to" pizza place, and we have been customers since it opened. At lunch we can get slices, or we can take the whole family for supper. Since the pandemic started we have been doing carryout. We think New York Pizza is the best!! Also love the garlic knots!

Haley Martin

We stopped here on our way into St Augustine. Started with a super fresh and delicious Caesar salad. We ordered a half/half pizza with my husband getting pineapple on his half. Our waitress accidentally put the order in with pineapple on the whole pizza. They put another whole pizza in with my half, sans pineapple, free of charge. We were fine with the pineapple all over the pizza but the owner was insistent on the other pizza. The garlic knots were to die for, pizza was fantastic and the service and hospitality was stellar. Thank you for a wonderful meal for the first night of our honeymoon!