Bakery Plus

Category: Bakery in Middletown, New York

Address: 383 211 E, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Phone: +18453442529

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 10AM–5PM

Wednesday: 10AM–5PM

Thursday: 10AM–5PM

Friday: 10AM–5PM

Saturday: 10AM–5PM

Reviews

Gina Floryan

Oct 18, 2022

Best bakery in and near Middletown. And the best cakes. Soooo good.

Gage Klipper

Sep 10, 2022

Absolute Covid fanatics, extremely rude to customers unfamiliar with their insane rules. Apparently the owners of Bakery Plus are still living in March 2020 and enjoy the smug satisfaction they get from scolding their morally inferior customers. If you’re this irrationally terrified of Covid in 2022, maybe you shouldn’t operate a public facing business. Or move to Brooklyn with the rest of the crazies. The linzer tarts are the only thing I ever really liked here, but definitely not worth the hassle to ever come back.

deadlysweet

Sep 3, 2022

i used to buy cakes here for my birthdays, not anymore! the owner is super last minute and unprofessional these days. i couldn't get the cake i wanted because she informed me last minute she didn't have the right ingredients.

Laura Vitaliani

Sep 2, 2022

2 customers allowed in the store at a time. The baked goods are so worth the wait. Freshest Cakes in town!👍😎

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 22, 2022
Deborah Mulqueen | Oct 22, 2021

Excellent

Read More

They speak spanish...??

Oscar Flores | Oct 22, 2021
Deborah Mulqueen | Oct 22, 2021

Not to my knowledge

Can you make a fun get to cake for a small wedding reception?

fran callan | Oct 22, 2021
Deborah Mulqueen | Oct 22, 2021

Fun get to cake,? What???

Read More

How much notice for a cake to be done

Faith moore | Oct 23, 2019
Laura Capparelli | Oct 23, 2019

2 to 3 days.. If ur wanting a larger specialty cake or pie . But they usually have a large selection to choose from on the days they're open

Read More

do you guys sell cake pops?

Marshall Dalencourt | Oct 23, 2018
food m | Oct 23, 2018

They do sell other desserts such as cookies and individual slices of cake but I don't remember seeing those there.

can a cake be made the same day

Eileen Crump | Oct 23, 2018
Denise Castillo (Dee) | Oct 23, 2018

Love that place and yes they have same day cakes

Read More

What day do you have napoleans

Joyce Baker | Oct 23, 2018
Karen Bedward | Oct 23, 2018

Yes, they do.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places