Tellers: An American Chophouse

Category: Steak house

Address: 605 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, USA

Phone: +16312777070

Opening hours

Sunday: 3–9PM

Monday: 11:30AM–10PM

Tuesday: 11:30AM–10PM

Wednesday: 11:30AM–10PM

Thursday: 11:30AM–10PM

Friday: 11:30AM–10PM

Saturday: 4–11PM

Reviews

Greg

Oct 21, 2022

Impress, reward, celebrate, Tellers is the place to spoil yourself.

Jennifer Kellenbenz

Oct 17, 2022

This is definitely an upscale steak house which isn't my thing. I am used to go to a place that gives you rolls or something to munch on while waiting for your food not here! Also they kept turning the lights up and down at one point it was quite dark in the dining area they then turned the lights back up and the lady next to our table said thank God so I wasn't the only one that thought it was too dark in there. I mean when eating I wanna be blessed to see my food. The prices are astronomical and the dishes are small. We didn't ask for a bottle of sparkling water the guy came to our table as we sat down and asked if we wanted some sparkling water my bf said yes and they filled his glass then sat the bottle down on the table. The bottle of water was already opened and he was going around filling glasses up but then sat the bottle on our table so we ended up being charged for it. So basically for that one glass of water we paid $8.50 cause we was charged for that opened bottle of water. If you enjoy paying a lot of money for small dishes the this is the place for you to go. You should dress nicely when going here also. I definitely wouldn't recommend this place to any of my friends and this was my first and last time there. Like I said the prices were very high for a small side of scalloped potatoes it was $15. I didn't even have the nerve to look at the dessert menu when he asked if we would like dessert we said no and left and went to Dunkin' donuts for dessert lol

Pigs Fly

Oct 13, 2022

Excellent food and service

conan cahill

Oct 11, 2022

Food was excellent. Porterhouse was as expected. Service was great, and the decor was beautiful.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

So need reservation?

Alecia Burrus | Oct 22, 2018
Simon Lewis | Oct 22, 2018

Not always necessary but recommended.

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 21, 2022
Paul A. Dacis | Oct 21, 2021

Reservation only. Tables are very well spaced out and staff wear masks at all time. Very clean and safe.

Read More

How are the duck fat fries?

Carolyn Santos | Oct 22, 2019
barry Ciralli | Oct 22, 2019

Duck fries are grate

Read More

Any dress code

Mercedes Perez | Oct 22, 2017
Michael Will | Oct 22, 2018

Any dress code, But dress up and make it a special occasion with your family or significant other

Read More

How do I order a drink for my son and his table on line?

Gerard V. Smith | Oct 21, 2020
Marisa | Oct 21, 2020

I would agree with Ira call the restaurant

Read More

is there any happy hour

allan goldner | Oct 21, 2020
El Flanagan | Oct 21, 2020

Not that I know of. Not really a "happy hour" vibe.

what brand of water do teller serve it's very good

melva mcbride | Oct 21, 2020
Gary Lefkowitz | Oct 21, 2020

Have no idea call them

when do you have wine tasting week

Robert Tomko | Oct 22, 2019
maria lova | Oct 22, 2019

You should call them directly and ask

What is the Friday ,July 5 price fix menu?

Patricia Cruz | Oct 22, 2019
maria lova | Oct 22, 2019

Check there website or call them

Is there a dress code

Ann Furey | Oct 22, 2019
Jacqueline Ortega | Oct 22, 2019

Casual is fine no sneaker

Read More

How is the parking

Jim F | Oct 22, 2019
Thomas McDermott | Oct 22, 2019

There is both valet and self parking in a private lot in the rear of the restaurant.

Read More

Does tellers accept credit/ gift cards for payment?

Roe Motta | Oct 22, 2019
Ron Lynch | Oct 22, 2019

As all the comments said above me, yup!

Read More

Can you take out food

Lynnann Westhoff | Oct 22, 2018
ALLYSON R | Oct 22, 2019

It’s a hassle to eat there sometimes .. long wait , I was curious about take out because the food is amazing I rather eat it at home sometimes if I can

Read More

Are children welcome?

brian trivitt | Oct 22, 2018
Kenya Rambert | Oct 22, 2018

Yes

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places