Nancy's Chicago Pizza - Midtown

Category: Pizza restaurant in Atlanta, Georgia

Address: 265 Ponce De Leon Ave NE, Atlanta, GA 30308, USA

Phone: +14048810111

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–9PM

Monday: 12–9PM

Tuesday: 12–9PM

Wednesday: 12–9PM

Thursday: 12–9PM

Friday: 12–10PM

Saturday: 12–10PM

Reviews

M

Oct 11, 2022

The crust of my deep dish pizza was doughy and could have used a little longer in the oven. Service was slow. The bartender was busy taking orders and walking around the restaurant even 20 minutes after our drink orders had been placed. I've also never heard of bacon on a Caesar salad and I personally didn't enjoy it. The live music was nice & our waitress was kind and apologetic about our wait. I heard her personally ask about them like 3 times

Tirth Patel

Oct 10, 2022

I’d give it a 0 if I could. Waited 2 hours for 2 pizzas. Kept saying 5 minutes more over and over. Had an attitude with me when went to ask about the food. Had the audacity to make us pay full price until I went up and said something. TLDR- Nancy a *insert bad word*.

E Ramsey

Oct 9, 2022

The pizza is always good and the employees were friendly and nice!!!

Jacob Palensky

Oct 7, 2022

Order 2 deep dish Pizzas. Under special instructions and order request, in two different spots, I wrote "No cheese". Instead of them calling to inform me they don't make deep dish with "no cheese", they took the time to make the pizza, took my time by me to driving and took payment from me; to make a pizza with cheese in it anyways.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they serve alcohol?

Jim Gillespie | Oct 15, 2018
Japanishaè Lì | Oct 15, 2018

They have beer, wine, and liquor. I had a peach margarita when I went. Our server had to check if the bartender was there though so, maybe they don't have alcohol all the time.

Read More

Best Stuffed Pizza in Atlanta, I'll drive 40 miles from Buford for some. Wish they'd open a location in Gwinnett. I love their buttery flaky crust!

Gina Barcourt B!rkoo | Oct 15, 2018
Jarvis Carter | Oct 15, 2018

You might want to leave this on the review side as well.😉

Best PIZZA you will ever EAT i drive 32 miles to get one I live in COVINGTON GA

Henderson Benjamin | Oct 15, 2018
Zirie Benton | Oct 15, 2018

I can vouch for that. Live in the same area and made the drive. Well worth it!!!!!!

Read More

What Chicago franchise does this deep dish most resemble?

Nicholas Czerkies | Oct 15, 2018
Amanda Kelley | Oct 15, 2018

I'd go with Gino's, im a bigger fan of Giordano's. Nancy's definitely worth going to if you cant make it to chicago for the real stuff.

Read More

Does Nancys serve beer?

stephen caldwell | Oct 15, 2019
Christopher Jones | Oct 15, 2019

I'm not sure if they serve alchohol.

Read More

Do they have a dining room or just patio?

Jennifer Lee | Oct 15, 2019
Kevin Haugabrook (Kev) | Oct 15, 2019

Both

Read More

Do they have parking?

Vantressa Wilson | Oct 15, 2019
Eboni Joy Carter | Oct 15, 2019

There's a parking lot down the side street. Just drive down hill on the western side street, going south from Ponce. Covered Parking lot is at end of the block.

Read More

Do you deliver to Phillips Lake Bluff?

cordell cooper | Oct 15, 2019
Yvette Davis | Oct 15, 2019

I do not know we ate in.

Do they have vegan cheese?

Justin Newman | Oct 15, 2019
Jarvis Carter | Oct 15, 2019

They do not unfortunately.

Read More

Do they sell by the slice?

Brian Penn | Oct 15, 2017
Broderick Mayo | Oct 15, 2017

Yes

Do you deliver?

sherry jones | Oct 15, 2017
Pamela Martin | Oct 15, 2017

Yes I am a customer

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places