Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC

Category: Bakery in New York

Address: 248 Broome St, New York, NY 10002, USA

Phone: +18554622292

Opening hours

Sunday: 8AM–8PM

Monday: 8AM–8PM

Tuesday: 8AM–8PM

Wednesday: 8AM–8PM

Thursday: 8AM–8PM

Friday: 8AM–10PM

Saturday: 8AM–10PM

Reviews

Caroline Schramka

Oct 10, 2022

It has always challenging to find baked goods that do not contain my allergens. But ever since I've discovered this place I keep returning to its location at Disney Springs. They generally have a wide variety of sweet treats, which are very tasty. Staff are always very friendly and helpful. If you have allergies, this is the place to shop!

jessica stocchi

Oct 1, 2022

Completely gluten-free pastry inexpensive by New York standards, but personally I found the place quite dirty and the desserts very nice, but tasteless.

Gayla Brooks

Sep 27, 2022

I made a custom cake order a month in advanced for my engagement/30th birthday party. This was a $300 cake. When it came time to pick up my cake, they just didn’t have it. They acknowledged that they did take all my info, and had my order. They just “didn’t make the cake”. After some back and forth, they ended up icing a small cake (less than half the size of the one I ordered, and the wrong flavor) with the design I wanted. They STILL charged me full price for the small cake. I was polite the whole time, they did say sorry, but i would think they should have offered me the cake for free. I was beyond disappointed. To have planned so far in advanced, to have them seem excited to make the cake, for them to just forget and say “eh, sorry” really was upsetting. Not even a further apology via email from the owner, just the girl on the phone.

ashley luz

Sep 25, 2022

EVERYTHING IS GLUTEN FREE!!! Delicious treats!!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they take custom orders for cupcakes? If so, how?

E D | Oct 14, 2019
Kenya | Oct 14, 2019

Yes they actually do but it's better to make the order in person.

Is your bakery tree nuts and peanuts free as well?

Jc Proctor | Oct 14, 2018
Kylie Park | Oct 14, 2018

The bakery states this on their website. Hope it helps! "We do not bake with most treenuts, peanuts, or soy.  We do use coconut in most of our products.  The FDA currently classifies coconuts as a treenut.  Also, all of our gluten free flours are processed on equipment that packages hazelnut, almond flours and soy."

Read More

are you nut free too?

A G Garg | Aug 14, 2022
David James Husted (DJ) | Aug 14, 2022

They are! Though they warn that they use Bob’s Red Mill (I think) flour which has a warning that while not containing nuts they are prepared in a facility that does use nuts. I think the machines that milk the flour are power washed and the first batch of flour is tossed to be as safe as possible.

What kind of flour do you use to make your bread

Jennifer Rampersad | Oct 14, 2019
P. J. | Oct 14, 2019

Everything they use is gravity-free. Love that!

Are you kosher?

Bnai Avraham Sisterhood | Oct 14, 2018
P. J. | Oct 14, 2018

If the mood fits...

Read More

Do they make sugar free cakes for diabetics?

Jennifer Cruz | Oct 14, 2018
Carmine Cavallo | Oct 14, 2018

I dont think they have anything ready to go but they are great and i am pretty sure if you spoke to them they could do something custom.

Do they use artificial food coloring, as in red#40 and the like?

Miriam Lipchik | Oct 14, 2018
Paul Gomez | Oct 14, 2018

No, they don't use artificial ingredients.

Read More

Hi is this bakery kosher ? Is it pat Israel ?

Rachely Baitch | Oct 14, 2017
danesh j | Oct 14, 2017

Yeah. They say it's Kosher.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places