Argyle Jewelers

Kelly Faller

Joe was absolutely wonderful to work with. My engagement ring was from brilliant earth, and I was very disappointed when my fiancé and I went into their showroom in Manhattan to find a wedding band. Argyle was recommended to us from our close friends who Joe had made a custom engagement ring and insert for, so we gave it a shot. Joe was wonderful and patient from day one, saw my vision and helped me create the wedding set of my dreams. He’s very knowledgeable and lets you know what’s possible and what might not be, and he was very accommodating to our budget. He truly loves to create and walked us through every step, wanting us to happy with a piece of jewelry I will wear for a lifetime. Highly recommend! And thank you Joe!

Jennifer Carney

Argyle Jewelers did an amazingly beautiful job resizing my wedding band and engagement ring- they made them look brand new! Betsy was sweet and knowledgeable and made me very comfortable to trust them with my special vintage jewelry. Highly recommend!

Joe Toth

The people who work here are extremely nasty and unprofessional… I actually was brought to tears in the store by the way I was spoken to and yell at by the jeweler himself … I wish I had it recorded and on video for all of you to hear because I’m still in shock by the way I was treated as a customer…. One of the prongs was bent on my engagement ring after 8 years of wearing it everyday … I went there the last week of June and they told me metal can not be bent back soo I would need all new prongs on my ring for my diamond to sit which would cost 250… less then a month and 1/2 later one of the prongs were completely bent again… I was upset because I just spent 250 for it to get fixed and felt the new prongs should have held up a lot longer than a month … when I went there the workers looked annoyed and the jeweler came out yelling (not even exaggerating) at me saying it was something I did and that my ring is filthy and unkept and that he bent the prong back ( soo basically here you go and bye ) I said I though metal couldn’t be bent back that’s why I paid for all the prongs to be replaced by you in the first place and when I looked at my ring to see the prong that he “fixed” The prong placement wasn’t even correctly placed and even with the rest…he continued to yell at me and even flung my ring down on the counter top … I was brought to tears … I went else where to get my ring fixed was treated ALOT better and they said if you have any problems come back and will fix it no charge ! As a Babylon resident for 16 years I’ll never go back here !

Michael Keller

If you are looking for unprecedented service and top-quality jewelry and diamonds at a competitive price,