Pagliai's Pizza

Category: Pizza restaurant in Charleston, Illinois

Address: 1600 Lincoln Ave, Charleston, IL 61920, USA

Phone: +12173453400

Opening hours

Sunday: 4–9PM

Monday: 4–9PM

Tuesday: 4–9PM

Wednesday: 4–9PM

Thursday: 4–9PM

Friday: 4–10PM

Saturday: 4–10PM

Reviews

linda [email protected]

Oct 9, 2022

Pagliai's has consistently made the best pizza around. Thin crust and quality ingredients and their homemade sauce has kept me their customer for over 50 years.

josh Lawson

Sep 30, 2022

Great food and great service

Donnie Sharp

Sep 7, 2022

Excellent customer service excellent food definitely recommend

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Are you open for dine in?

Marsha Hollinger | Oct 9, 2020
josh Lawson | Oct 9, 2020

Yes they are open for dinning in

Read More

Can you dine inside yet?

Carol winchester | Oct 9, 2021
Jane Fisher | Oct 9, 2021

Yes! But beware...they're VERY busy, and you'll stand in line for a long time waiting to pay due to the fact there is only one register for dine in, carry out and the delivery boys...it seems there could be a better way...like adding another register for dine in and letting the wait staff handle that from the table. But, the food is, as always, excellent.

Read More

Dairy free or no lactose cheese?

Noelia Vera | Oct 9, 2021
Patricia Albert | Oct 9, 2021

No

Do we need to call for reservations ? We live about 8 miles east of Mattoon so we don't want to drive all the way over and then have to wait to get in.

Marsha Hollinger | Oct 9, 2020
Jami Vonbehren | Oct 9, 2020

Best pizza in our tri county area

Read More

How long does it take to make and cook a large thin crust mushroom pizza?

A Google User | Oct 10, 2019
Kaitlin Titus | Oct 10, 2019

About 15 minutes depending on how busy they are.

Read More

how far is pagliai's from the greenup exit off I 70 West

Edward L` Jones Sr | Oct 10, 2019
Kaitlin Titus | Oct 10, 2019

About 25-30 minutes north on rt 130.

Read More

How much are their pizzas

Teresa Geib | Oct 10, 2019
George Shriver | Oct 10, 2019

Worth the price best pizza found in Illinois, Missouri, and Arkansas. Spaghetti special are great too.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places