Old Time Pizza

Matthew Wagner

Pizza is still decent, but the wait times are outrageous. We waited over an hour for our pizza. A gentleman came in with his parrot and ate in the restaurant and the owner never even batted an eye. I don't want to be eating next to someone with a bird on their shoulder. That screams unsanitary. It's not like it used to be when Stumpy owned it. Slower service, smaller pizza, and lower standards. We won't be going back.

M Murphy

New owners. Prices are outrageous and our orders have been messed up the last two times we have been there. $17 for a sub and fries with no drink. Ridiculous!

Teresa Smith

Food was good, but our pizza was burnt all around the edges. It tasted good towards the middle though.

Carla Humble

Wonderful hometown feel. Wonderful service. Wonderful fresh food. We had tossed salad-- very fresh and tasty; bread sticks-- hot and fresh u have a choice of dripping sauce-- cheese, garlic butter and Marinera. Supreme pizza-- lots of cheese, veggies and meats it was great. We will order or come here again.