Mario's

Category: Italian restaurant

Address: Old School House Square, 212 Main St, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733, USA

Phone: +16317518840

Opening hours

Sunday: 11:30AM–12AM

Monday: 11:30AM–12AM

Tuesday: 11:30AM–12AM

Wednesday: 11:30AM–12AM

Thursday: 11:30AM–12AM

Friday: 11:30AM–12AM

Saturday: 11:30AM–12AM

Reviews

Sun Shine

Oct 2, 2022

A great place with excellent service! We will be back! Really enjoyed pizza, a cocktail, appetizers and kids enjoyed their food. Really good place to have an Italian meal in romantic ambiance.

Surfer Girl Jewels

Oct 1, 2022

What a beautiful place!!!! The relaxed ambience of the bar/lounge is popular with guests and the live band added to the excitement of the evening. Not only is the waitstaff adorbs but super sweet!! My girlfriend got the meatballs (5⭐️) my friend got the Eggplant (5⭐️) my other friend got the claims (5⭐️) and unfortunately I ordered the seasonal veggies and pasta but doubled the veggies and only half the pasta…. It came backwards, barely any veggies and way too much pasta, pasta was hard and veggies were not steamed properly (2⭐️). The owners are adorable older sweet gentleman who came over to say hello. I would definitely go back and try again, but not the veggie meal❤️. This place is super cool❤️🤙🏼❤️.

Boston

Sep 30, 2022

Excellent food, service and ambience here. Looking forward to my next meal here.

Jean Pinks

Sep 13, 2022

Excellent eggplant rollatine and seafood fra diavolo. Good drinks, good service, we'll definitely be back!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Hi do you do large partys? Between 30-40

Marguerite King | May 11, 2022
Jimmy Enright | May 11, 2022

Yes

Read More

Do you deliver??

Cheryl Tinsley | Oct 9, 2017
M “Supershafts” J | Oct 9, 2017

They don't deliver

Read More

Is Mario's restaurant open yet since the fire?

Sharon Siebert | Oct 8, 2020
Frank Giuliano | Oct 8, 2020

Marios restaurant is still closed till further notice, the fire happened July 31st at 7:23 pm. Hopefully its open soon, thats a great restuarant.

Read More

Would this restaurant accommodate a group of 20?

Silvia Padron | Oct 9, 2019
Robert Sommese | Oct 9, 2019

Yes. Easy make reservations

Read More

Does a Marios have happy hour on Saturday?

Denise stubberfield | Oct 9, 2018
Joanne Matovich | Oct 9, 2018

No

Read More

We want to bring our son for dinner Sunday 1/14/18.Do we need to make reservations?

Helen Tzortzis | Oct 9, 2018
Joanne Matovich | Oct 9, 2018

Usually you don't need a reservation. But it can't hurt to make one.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places