Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe

Category: Bakery

Address: W2360 Kiel Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061, USA

Phone: +19208941776

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: Closed

Thursday: Closed

Friday: 9AM–6PM

Saturday: 7AM–4PM

Reviews

Jim Hoffman

Aug 6, 2022

They make the very best glazed doughnut I have ever had. And I've had my share at dozens of places in my life. I first had it at the Sheboygan Farmer's Market and it was so good, we went directly to their farm shop to buy more. They have a good variety of baked goods at their Sheboygan Farmer's Market stand, and while they didn't have tons of variety in the walk-in shop, the doughnuts were tremendous and worth the drive. I understand they also take pre-orders for all their baked goods, which is a smart idea.

Jeana Ditter

Nov 2, 2021

Their custard filled doughnuts are so full of custard and delicious. Best around! But only on Saturdays.

sara hess

Dec 18, 2019

We just received a box of the English Toffee as a gift - it is the BEST I have ever had! Delicious! I can’t wait to stop by your shop to see what else you have!

robert Wilson

Apr 19, 2018

Very cute little Amish Bakery. Pies, doughnuts, cookies, bread, turnovers, noodles, angel food cake. So good and all fresh made. Cash or check only. No credit cards.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the bake shoppe hours and are they open now or later date?

Sheila Schultz | Apr 15, 2022
Kristin Nolan | Apr 16, 2022

They are open for the season. Normally Fridays 9-6 & Saturdays 7-4, but they will not be open this Friday (Good Friday).

Where exactly is the store?

A Google User | Jul 3, 2021
Jamie Pennington | Jul 4, 2021

It is in New Holstein. They are only open Thursday, Friday, And Saturday. I was just there Saturday there stuff is always amazing. It's 2300 Kiel Rd. New Holstein, WI. It's a little out there but so worth it!

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places