Nicky's Pizzeria

Carlos Martinez

Finally found an authentic NY style pizzeria! I'm from NY and haven't found anything as authentic here in SC as I did at Nicky's tonight. The Stromboli was different (used to it being closed up) but it was sooo delicious. The mussels were perfectly cooked and the sauce wasn't acidic... on point! The calamari was prefectly fried with just flour and without the breading that mostly all the other places use. Next, I will try the pizza because from seeing the other tables order pizza they looked like real NY pizza.

George Renard

We stopped by our favorite pizza place to enjoy the perfect SC weather on their patio. Cold Yuengling drafts and garlic knots to start. Instead of pizza this stop, we split a Caesar salad and a meatball sub. Definitely one of my must-have sandwiches here. The Italian sub is also excellent. Haley provided great service!

James Strainer

Took my NY in-laws and they enjoyed it. Loved the veal parmigian. Huge portions and excellent red sauce. The pizza is the best in Lexington. The decor is simple, nothing fancy, feels like a good friend's back patio. We had a local HS …

DL Owens

I don't get all the great reviews. We stopped in based on that and were very disappointed. Probably the greasiest pizza I've ever consumed. I felt like I was injecting straight up grease into my arteries. The crust was all wrong, cheap greasy pepperoni (not being cooked correctly at the right temp), cheese had no stretch. Just an epic fail and overpriced.