Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Neenah/Menasha

Ris L

I absolutely love ordering from this location! The pizzas are always cooked to perfection and the toppings are generous. The sandwiches are tasty and full of flavor. And they have a big variety of sides- something the other chains don't. Whether I call in my order or do it through the website I always get amazing customer service. The staff are really friendly and are always smiling. The delivery drivers always bring my food hot and they follow any instructions I leave for them. The lobby is clean and the soda cooler is well stocked. Wait times may be longer during rush times but it's totally worth the wait!

Abigail S

I ordered a simple cheese pizza and had it delivered to my home. Once it arrived I found not two, but three long strands of hair both on top of and inside of the pizza once I cut it. Absolutely ridiculous and I'm disgusted at what the hygiene must be.

Abbie Cleveland

Got the chicken alfredo and it was delicious! The "side salad" that came with my pasta was HUGE!! It was delicious and probably weighed more than my pasta. The service was super fast. They delivered faster than the original estimated time. It was crazy! Loved it and will order it again. 👍

Penny Pagel

Pizza delivered right at time I requested to my assisted living facility. Pizza delicious Definitely will order again. My friend and I really enjoyed it. Would highly recommend the thin crust pizza