Lib's Supper Club

Category: Italian restaurant

Address: 106 W 5th St, Elmira, NY 14901, USA

Phone: +16077332752

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 4–8PM

Wednesday: 4–8PM

Thursday: 4–8PM

Friday: 4–8PM

Saturday: 4–8PM

Reviews

Holly Wilson

Sep 25, 2022

Perfect for date night, or family meal. Lovely ambience. Waitress was really nice too. Can’t wait to be back!

Matthew McNeely

Sep 14, 2022

Great food! But the lighting, seating, and the silverware is very poor. You have to use a flashlight to look at the menu. The seats are from 1980, And the silverware quality is just above plastic silverware I get from KFC. For the money spent I would expect a better quality experience.

Ang Leshick

Sep 13, 2022

We always have excellent food and service at Lib's Supper Club! Tonight did not disappoint. Food is on point.

Tammy Odell

Sep 12, 2022

Need better lighting and more kid options but food was amazing so was the service

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What sweet wines do you have?

R Griffin | Sep 29, 2019
James Symonds | Sep 29, 2019

I didn't have any wine but my dinner was great

Do they do takeout?

Andy Giles | Sep 29, 2018
Shannon Crandall | Sep 29, 2019

Yes. However during the busy season we will not do takeout on Fridays and most Saturdays after 5:00/5:30pm.

Read More

Do you have a private dining room for about 30 people?

Butch Talada | Sep 29, 2018
Jerry Baker | Sep 29, 2018

They sure do

Read More

Do they have cards?

Miranda Mickley | Dec 2, 2021
Jamie Edmister | Dec 2, 2021

That have gift certificates!

Do we still have to wear masks here, after New York state adopted the new CDC recommendation?

Filippo Costanzo | Sep 28, 2021
Kinglizard | Sep 28, 2021

No!!!

Does Libs do curbside pickup?

Charlene Zearfoss | Sep 28, 2020
Steve Allison | Sep 28, 2020

Yes call ahead and pick up at the bar

Does Libs make the Italian sausage in house?

Terry Kingsley | Sep 29, 2019
Patrick Gargano | Sep 29, 2019

I'm not sure, but the food is excellent!

Could you take little kids here?

Shelby Davis | Sep 29, 2019
Roy Sours | Sep 29, 2019

Yes it is a family oriented restaurant

Read More

Are they open New Year's Eve.

Mike Mckay | Sep 29, 2019
Jim Wheeler | Sep 29, 2019

Not positive. Normally closed Sunday and Monday. I'd bet on open tomorrow night

Read More

Do I need reservations for just 2-3 people?

Kurt Derenzo | Sep 29, 2018
Shannon Crandall | Sep 29, 2019

We are a very high volume establishment. Reservations are always recommended especially Fridays and Saturdays.

Read More

Do they take credit cards

Thomas Ferris | Sep 29, 2018
Shannon Crandall | Sep 29, 2019

Yes. All major Credit Cards.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places