Duryea's Montauk

S Ten

Not the Lobster Deck I knew and loved. Wondering what happened to my other lobster claw, somehow it was removed and replaced with a smaller claw? No bib, no buckets for shells, somehow I get the impression this is not truly a place to enjoy lobster 🦞

J Marchese

Gorgeous spot on the water, fresh seafood dishes, beautiful people and a little bit of a Hamptons scene. Yes, the food is overpriced, but so is every restaurant in the Hamptons - this is no exception. So know going in that you will be spending a good amount of money for your meal. Another important thing to keep in mind: They are not considered a “full service restaurant”, but a “fish market” sort of business - therefore you will have to go and order/pay for your food at the booth, and then they will bring the food to your table. Don’t expect fine dining service because that is NOT what they are about (even though the prices might make you think otherwise LOL). As long as you go in with these expectations, I guarantee you’ll have a great experience. Lastly, if you are a fan of lobster, their Lobster Cobb Salad is a MUST!

BK

Definatley at pricier end of the spectrum but is worth it once factor in the quality, setting and broader experience. Clam bake was certainly a highlight. Minus one for lack of cocktails and desserts.

Debbi Melman

The most rude host & hostess with attitudes. Outdoor dining but they would not allow my service dog in. She’s 4 pounds and in a bag with her tag. Possibly illegal? I have dined there with her in years past. Felt like we were being profiled. This pup has been by my side in the finest 5 star restaurants throughout the world. If you like dogs stay clear and go to The Surf Lodge for the same gorgeous sunsets! 🐾🐾