Papa Joe's Pizzeria

Mark Schmigel

Their pizza was very good, we all liked the crust. The wings didn't look like they were medium but the heat was just right. We asked for crispy and unfortunately they weren't as crispy as we had hoped but they were still good.

Amanda Dalrymple

OWNER IS THE NASTIEST PERSON PLACE IS SO DIRTY, WORKERS ARE HORRIBLE AND YOULL WAIT 2 HOURS FOR A MEDIOCRE PIZZA. is the worst business ever. There aren’t many options in this town but I still would never give this place my money again.

James Aman

Never had a bad meal from these guys which is surprising because a lot of these small town pizza places get comfortable & just don’t care at papa joes The food has always been delivered hot & on time great food & friendly

Elizabeth Britton

I tried this place again, against my own intuition, and once again they failed. Disappointing and blah wings, pizza and subs. I would rather spend $5.00 a gallon on gas and drive to Ruck's in Honeoye Falls, Vincenzo's in Lakeville or Giovanni's in Geneseo to enjoy good food than order from this place ever again.