Stickney's Restaurant

AndiamoAdventure

For some reason, for such an amazing luxury resort, the food (and food service) were unfortunately disappointing. When prices are high, expectations are high, and that’s why we need to share a few thoughts. We researched all the Google reviews for the restaurants on site, and sadly none of them have outstanding reviews, but we decided to go in with an open mind. We decided to go with Stickney’s for dinner, but I had the hardest time making a reservation. The website emphasizes making reservations, and so I had left a voicemail 1 of the 3 times I tried calling to leave a reservation, and they never got back to me. So we went the day of, and they told us we couldn’t eat at 6:30 since they were booked so we took 6pm. They ended up never having a full house, maybe 50% capacity when we finished dinner at 7:15. We had also asked to outside and the hostess said “no.”…which is fine but we didn’t understand as the tables and chairs were already out there , yet no guests were allowed to sit outside (but they were allowed to sit outside for Rosewood). Okay. So we ordered burgers which were fine and safe to go with, just nothing outstanding whatsoever for a $23 burger. We didn’t feel the flavor was worth the cost, therefore for dining we’d feel 3/5 stars We’d come back again, but only if able to book reservations with more ease and with amenities promised to be open. If you enjoyed this review, check out our adventure couple Instagram @andiamoadventure

Lisa Armes

Nice menu, delicious execution. A bit on the pricy side for what you get but the fries are spectacular. Skip the caprese salad. The tomatoes are unruly large causing a skewed tomato to cheese ratio.

Sara S

My husband and I ordered the filet, we ordered right away thinking it might take awhile. My husband ordered a drink before we ordered. We split a Caesar salad. The salad came out right away, right as we finished the meal came and then his drink came. He ordered the drink thinking he would get it before the meal. We were surprised it took so long for a drink. When the food came out so fast, we were surprised, but it was luke warm which was disappointing. Our waiter was arrogant and acted like he did not care about giving us good service which was disappointing. I understand we are in a different time, they were not super busy but they seemed to have enough staff so that did not seem to be the problem.

James Kasal

Our server Peter was amazing, the view is incredible and the food is very good