Cayuga Lake Creamery

Category: Ice cream shop

Address: 8421 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847, USA

Phone: +16075329492

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–8PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 12:30–8PM

Wednesday: 12–8PM

Thursday: 12–8PM

Friday: 12–8PM

Saturday: 12–8PM

Reviews

Eva Reynolds

Jul 3, 2022

Great environment and cute shop, but I personally didn’t think the ice cream was worth the cost based on the flavors we tried. With a tip, 2 one scoop dishes was $15. (We tried salted caramel and pistachio. Pistachio was rather bland and both seem like they could use a bit of salt, actually. There was a family sitting near us that purchased the same flavors and agreed w/the above sentiments.)

Momma Bear Buckley

Jun 6, 2022

The ice cream is so rich & creamy! Always enjoy & try to pick a different flavor.

Stephen Wallace

Feb 11, 2022

Tip:Tiny parking lot in the front but there is more parking down and in the rear. As per every business during covid not a lot of staff so there may be a delay ordering/serving. Big selection of ice cream flavours. Prices a tad high but the taste is better than store bought ice cream.

Anthony Pero

Sep 4, 2021

Not sure how this has so many good reviews. The ice cream sundae has no flavor to it, the service was SO slow, and the workers weren’t very nice. One customer was complaining that their food took 40 minutes to get. Overall, Dairy Queen tastes better.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Who won the raffle? Thanks 😊

Emily Artley | Feb 1, 2018
Roberta Walker | Feb 2, 2018

The winner will be picked on December 11th.

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Jan 31, 2021
Ken Gravenstede | Feb 1, 2021

Mask and gloves. Only takeout

Do you have salty caramel truffle? What kinds of sundaes do you have?

Grace Benjamin | Feb 1, 2020
Sarah drumheller | Feb 2, 2020

No, just Seneca Salt Caramel. Traditional sundaes and usually a rotating one too.

Read More

Do you have lactose free ice cream? Do you have orange pineapple ice cream?

Ellie Pelletier | Feb 1, 2019
Jeff Kostick | Feb 2, 2019

Yes we have sorbets which are dairy free but we don't have orange pineapple now.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places