Pizza Time

Category: Pizza restaurant in St. Augustine, Florida

Address: 124 St George St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA

Phone: +19048190133

Opening hours

Sunday: 10:30AM–11PM

Monday: 10:30AM–10:30PM

Tuesday: 10:30AM–10:30PM

Wednesday: 10:30AM–10:30PM

Thursday: 10:30AM–10:30PM

Friday: 10:30AM–11PM

Saturday: 10:30AM–11PM

Reviews

Daniel Burnham (Caspar36)

Sep 23, 2022

I could write an essay on how terrible this place was and how they treated me! They lied to me three times (said there was a sign that says 'only cash' when there wasn't, Then changed it to say they weren't allowed to put a sign that said that because of "the law" which showed the first lie (and what law could that possibly be?), lied about the machine "doesn't have a space for water" (but they sold bottles for $3.50 a piece). They embarrassed me twice in front of several other customers ("Sir, we have to keep this line moving." (When I had a legitimate concern) "There's a sign that says cash only out there (a lie)") They don't take a debit card at all (to save them that $.35 service charge) and shrugged when I said I didn't have cash. BUT THEY DO have an ATM that I can get cash for a $3 fee right next to the register (hmm). The lady at the register looked like she wouldn't care if I died in front of her, rolled her eyes and never smiled. Another lady (the "we have to keep this line moving along") walked away while I was voicing my concerns. They had no sign that said they only take cash, but have AT LEAST 5 SHOWING THEY ARE THE SECOND BEST PIZZA IN ST AUGUSTINE PER TRIP ADVISOR (which coincidentally was a 7 year old news report). By the way, the pizza? Meh. I've had much better. This was the worst experience from a customer service standpoint I have received in a very long time, and they do not DESERVE customers if they treat people like I was treated. 0 Stars if I could

ChawnA Franco

Sep 23, 2022

The food was good but they don’t have the prices anywhere in site so their pizza slices were pretty expensive and it’s cash only, which you only find out at the register. They do have atms but they charge you a a hefty fee which is just a maneuver to make more money.

Michael Toney

Sep 21, 2022

Pizza ok it was different

Jb

Sep 19, 2022

Always good food

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

This is not a question...this is a statement. One of the best 🍕 east of the Mississippi.

MARK KONICK | Sep 23, 2018
Steve Imre | Sep 23, 2018

I'm born and raised in bronx,ny and this is the best pizza around here.it's pretty dam authentic.my favorite.I drive from jacksonville to st Augustine.it's the only pizza I'll eat.

Read More

My big surprise, we bought a pizza and they tell me that I have to eat it in the street because the tables are for customers with a slice of pizza. having space t tables available. What a bad service.

Pablo Cruz | Sep 23, 2019
Humanity wins ! (Humanity wins) | Sep 22, 2020

Love their pizza so much... stop crying about where to sit.... just cause u got dollars ... doesnt buy you a seat..... Go eat this awesome pizza !

Read More

How much is a slice?

Maria Saccone | Sep 23, 2019
Jennifer McCarthy | Sep 23, 2019

Like 3 or 4 bucks, I think? I never pay attention, money is no object at that place. Worth every dime and then some.

Read More

Are small dogs allowed?

Barbara Lucci | Sep 23, 2018
jonathan curtis | Sep 23, 2018

No. Not animals

Read More

Is it open on Christmas day?

Marian de Pérez | Jan 25, 2022
Andrew Hernandez | Jan 25, 2022

Kinda

We've missed your outstanding pizza. Would love some today, but Do you require masks? Thank you

Moon Beam | Sep 22, 2020
Michael Prohonic | Sep 22, 2020

I was there on Saturday. No masks. Masks were never required in Florida. There are just a couple businesses that have a mask policy but they are few and far between. The pizza was amazing as always!

Read More

Has Pizza Time reopened for business. The phone number is not in service? Miss our Brooklyn Pizza 😢 since quarantine!

Theresa Mayer | Sep 22, 2020
Theresa Mayer | Sep 22, 2020

We just drove by. They are OPEN. Just ordered our Brooklyn Pizza😊😊 they have phone issues.

Do you know when you will reopen?

Tami Clemmons | Sep 22, 2020
Ian Lee | May 25, 2022

Sadly, they have.

Do you have gluten free by the slice?

Isaac Arredondo | Sep 22, 2020
Javier Alvarez | Sep 22, 2020

There is an excellent pizza and many options, so they probably have gluten free

Hi Is this place expensive? How much for 2 people ?

Angie traveling | Sep 23, 2019
Bob Stolberg | Sep 23, 2019

Not too pricey. Cash only!!! Excellent Pizza

Read More

Can you get it to go?

susan lawrence | Sep 23, 2019
Stugee G. | Sep 23, 2019

Takes about 35 minutes to get a pie made from scratch. Amazing.

Read More

Is there outside seating?

susan lawrence | Sep 23, 2019
Juan Cintron | Sep 23, 2019

Nah... Inside is the only option.

Read More

Can you order for pickup?

M S | Sep 23, 2019
Timothy Hsu | Sep 23, 2019

No

Is there a parking lot or a place to park?

Jair Zúñiga Técnico en Peluquería. | Sep 23, 2019
Farileyme Farileyme | Sep 23, 2019

I deeply apologize I don't do Spanish but it's a good place to eat I like it if you want to know their times and what they sell I would suggest you Google them or call them but you won't go wrong happy eating

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places