Cooperstown Cheese Company

Category: Gourmet grocery store

Address: 3941 NYS, NY-28, Milford, NY 13807, USA

Phone: +19782574635

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–6PM

Monday: 10AM–6PM

Tuesday: 10AM–6PM

Wednesday: 10AM–6PM

Thursday: 10AM–6PM

Friday: 10AM–6PM

Saturday: 10AM–6PM

Reviews

Erica Wells

Jul 31, 2022

Stopped here today after driving by multiple times ... bought a chesse cake and a single slice chocolate cake and 2 plain dounuts for my 67 year old father who Is picky ... well big compliments cause when he likes everything I bring home it's a mini miracle and he raved about the cake and dounuts... so we try cheese cake it's so good .. hands down best crust I have ever had on any cheese cake and I have tried alot .. we will be back .. thank you

Steve Schwinn

Jun 15, 2022

Great selection of cheeses, jams, and other items.

Jc avery

Apr 30, 2022

Cute shop, friendly owners, BEST CHEESECAKE!!!!

A.R. Morgante

Jan 27, 2022

Great cheese! Always find them at the local farmer's markets in Westchester County. While attending the Jan 22 Tarrytown Market, I bought the Jersey Girl Cheese with spring onion. As usual, did not disappoint. Key compliments: Raw Cows milk, no antibiotics, nor artificial hormones.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Is the rind on MARIELLE edible? I'm always a bit scared I might be eating wax but I do love edible rinds... Please enlighten me!

Craig Mawhirt | Sep 17, 2020
Kimberly M | Sep 17, 2021

We were there yesterday Any cheeses that have add ins. Like spices or herbs will have a wax coating just on the outermost rind. Everything we purchased is vacuum sealed.

The cheesecake was out of this world. Was it Italian cheesecake? And do you have a full one for sale? Interested for birthday cake for a friend.

Ann Jordan | Sep 17, 2020
Cooperstown Cheese Company | Apr 20, 2022

Hi Ann, It's not an Italian cheesecake, which usually contains ricotta. Don modified his grandmother's recipe and it contains sour cream and cream cheese. I can't tell you more or Don would have my head. Glad you like it. Sharon

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places