Black & Blue Steak and Crab, Buffalo NY

Category: Steak house in Amherst, New York

Address: 5493 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14221, USA

Phone: +17168392525

Opening hours

Sunday: 4–9PM

Monday: 4–9PM

Tuesday: 4–9PM

Wednesday: 4–9PM

Thursday: 4–9PM

Friday: 4–10PM

Saturday: 4–10PM

Reviews

william hedges

Jun 18, 2022

Came here for our anniversary and everything was great. The special dry aged steak was the best I’ve ever had from anywhere ever, it had me making inappropriate faces it was so good. The crab and lobster fondue was great. Deserts were also extremely good. Our server was very personable and did a great job. I would recommend this establishment for any special occasion. We will be back for our next anniversary.

J D

Mar 10, 2022

We recently went to black and blue to celebrate an anniversary. They have a nice atmosphere at the restaurant. The food is pretty good. I would agree with some of the other reviews that the price is pretty high for what you get. To be fair, I had a lot of hype behind black and blue from a lot of people before I came there. The meal was good and our family did enjoy themselves! There was a mistake with our bill, but the restaurant manager was really good in getting it fixed quickly! It's really much appreciated on a business will go the extra mile to help make sure customers are treated right! I would definitely recommend this place! Our server was also very nice and she came back to check on our table a few times during our meal which was much appreciated!

Robert Wagner

Feb 18, 2022

Excellent place to eat. A bit pricy, but not outrageous. Not going to mark down on price as I looked at menu ahead of time so I knew what I was getting into. Greeted and seated immediately upon arrival. Ambiance was fantastic and service was wonderful. Waitress gave great recommendations and actually seemed to enjoy doing her job. When making our reservation online, we advised it was for our anniversary and we received a complimentary piece of chocolate cake. Wonderful experience and will definitely go again.

Savannah Johnson

Dec 22, 2021

Had a wonderful dinner date here, celebrating our two year anniversary! The staff was the best, super personable and professional! Everyone was so kind, from entering to leaving. (I hope I'm spelling their names right) Kaitlin and Olivia …

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

How much is the prime rib?

Pamela Latham | Dec 29, 2019
James Bitterman | Dec 30, 2019

If you have to ask. Don't go there

Could we bring our child to this place? He's just under 2 years old.

Lance Nelson | Aug 30, 2021
Ruth Nowakowski | Aug 31, 2021

It depends on the child. I don't want to be "that person", but I personally do not want to spend that kind of money to listen to a small child scream and cry. But a quiet and well behaved child would be fine.

Read More

Is there a $20.19 promotion this week?

Brett Stanwich | Dec 29, 2019
Kaleb Benton | Dec 30, 2019

Yes. October 7th-13th first course Mixed Greens Salad served with tomato in a herb buttermilk vinaigrette choice of entree | $20.19 Grilled 9oz Bistro Filet served with whipped garlic potatoes & asparagus, topped with a port wine butter Pan Seared Salmon served over a roasted corn succotash with bacon, shallot, haricots verts & wilted spinach with a butternut squash puree choice of entree | $30.19 Grilled 9oz Bistro Filet with Grilled Shrimp (3) served with whipped garlic potatoes & asparagus, topped with a port wine butter Dry Aged Pork Chop served with a chorizo cornbread stuffng, wilted greens and a sage brown butter entree | $40.19 Grilled 7oz Filet with Pan Seared Scallops (2) served with haricots verts & a three cheese truffe potato with a side of gorgonzola cream sauce dessert Nutella Mousse served with fresh whipped cream, candied hazelnuts & chocolate crumbles

Is the side room (to the left up the stairs) available to do a 40th Anniversary Party of 12 people. We will be renewing our vows?

Jo Ann Ward | Dec 29, 2019
Maria Moran | Dec 30, 2019

I am not sure! Just call them and question!

Read More

What's on the menu

Willie Ridgeway | Dec 29, 2019
Micah Smith | Dec 30, 2019

If you look on their website it has a listing of their menu items.

Read More

Do I need a reservation?

Jayme Harper | Dec 29, 2018
Black & Blue Steak and Crab, Buffalo NY (Owner) | Dec 30, 2018

Thank you for your question, Jayme. You do not need a reservation to join us for dinner, in the lounge or at the bar. However, we do suggest making reservations to ensure there is no wait to accommodate your party.

Read More

does Black and Blue take charge cards

Bruce Colucci | Dec 29, 2017
Brenda Shaw | Dec 30, 2017

Yup, they kind of have to. Worth it though.

Read More

Is there a dress code? I ask because I'm wearing sweatpants currently....

William Price | Dec 29, 2017
Anton Henny C. Black Hicks | Dec 30, 2017

No dress code. Very nice decor however.

Read More

I am looking for a room for 20 people ,wife's 60 Birthday, Oct 14

Kevin Cox | Dec 29, 2017
Alex H. | Dec 30, 2017

They had a good sized room at the front that should accommodate that many people. The food and service is outstanding.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places