Yoder's Restaurant & Amish Village

Category: Restaurant in Sarasota, Florida

Address: 3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239, USA

Phone: +19419557771

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 7AM–8PM

Tuesday: 7AM–8PM

Wednesday: 7AM–8PM

Thursday: 7AM–8PM

Friday: 7AM–8PM

Saturday: 7AM–8PM

Reviews

Tammy Patterson

Sep 15, 2022

Food is excellent and be prepared to take food home with you.

Jake Norlin

Sep 15, 2022

it was good. didnt love it but had fun

Kathleen Thomas

Sep 14, 2022

I throughly enjoyed their vegetable and fruit market, bakery, and restaurant. They also have a gift shop. I love Yoders everything!!

Heather Frechette

Sep 14, 2022

Food and service was great! We especially loved the carrot salad and peanut butter cream pie.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do you take reservation?

Alethea Williams | Sep 16, 2019
Dale S | Sep 16, 2019

No Reservations you can order takeout or you can wait for a table

Read More

Do you sell whole pies?

michelle stockton | Sep 16, 2018
Leanna Hershberger | Sep 16, 2018

Yes they do. You may want to call ahead to place an order for pick up.

Read More

Will you be open on Labor Day and what hours? Thanks.

Jeanne Nelson | Sep 16, 2017
Ed Young | Sep 16, 2017

Yes they will be open.

Read More

Can I order take out during breakfast hours?

ttgk | Jun 17, 2022
David Legg | Jun 17, 2022

I'm sure you can.

Read More

When do you serve Rivel soup?

chuck csaszar | Oct 20, 2021
Bard Keeler | Oct 20, 2021

It was in the menu when we were there on September 4.

Read More

Opened on Sundays?

Dee Trench | Sep 15, 2021
Brenda Woods | Sep 15, 2021

Closed on Sunday

Read More

Hi, do you do Thanksgiving meals for a family? We are a family of 7 and traveling to Siesta Key for Thanksgiving. Thanks!

Jennifer Phillips, Realtor | Sep 15, 2021
Rick | Sep 15, 2021

They also have meals that you can order ahead and take to go. Typically, have Turkey and the fixings. As the others said call ahead to see what they will offer for Thanksgiving. Always fresh made desserts too.

Read More

Do u make pies for the holidays

Bob Barnard | Sep 15, 2020
Eric DeMello | Sep 15, 2020

Great pies ! Order in advance.

Read More

Do you recommend reservations for lunch? Looking at Nov 14 at 11am for 5 people?

Wanda Alderman | Sep 15, 2020
Lauri Vanacker | Sep 15, 2020

Not sure they take them. Call before..

Is the pumpkin cream pie on the menu yet? It's to die for.

john sullivan | Sep 15, 2020
James Burkholder | Sep 15, 2020

Yes had it last week.

Are you making custard pie

Tina Meyer | Sep 16, 2019
Nancy Portz | Sep 16, 2019

You need to call the restaurant to see what pies they are making on any given day

Has Yoder's summer menu started yet?

Cliff Bloodsworth | Sep 16, 2019
Joan Morales | Sep 16, 2019

Yes!

Read More

Do you do Birthday cakes

Charlene Rifelj | Sep 16, 2019
Victoria Frame | Sep 16, 2019

They make amazing birthday cakes. I would say they're better than Publix. 💜🎂💜

Do you take credit cards

Chuck Zodl | Sep 16, 2019
greg crosby | Sep 16, 2019

Cash or Card

Read More

Can I order to go?

Bill Wilson | Sep 16, 2019
Yusenkyo | Sep 16, 2019

Yes you can order to go, just call the restaurant, also I know I saw these bread pudding don't remember seeing the corn fritter could be seasonal?

Read More

Do you offer gift cards?

Ramona Koning | Sep 16, 2019
Judith Pankratz | Sep 16, 2019

Yes

Read More

Do they take credit cards?

Laura Samuel | Sep 16, 2018
Lanfranko coro | Sep 16, 2018

Yes, indeed

Read More

Y

Anonymous | Sep 14, 2022
Anonymous | Sep 14, 2022

o

Open July 4th?

Nikki Bicknell | Sep 16, 2018
Conrad Vazquez | Sep 16, 2018

Open until 2pm and just the restaurant.

Read More

How is the foid and service there?

Mary Hueckel | Sep 16, 2018
Richard Tasker | Sep 16, 2018

Not sure how the foid is... However, the food is very good. Down home cooking with generous portions. Service is fast and friendly. Edit: I forgot, the pies are huge and excellent.

Read More

Will you be opened Thanksgiving.

William Husted | Sep 16, 2018
Julia Schlabach | Sep 16, 2018

They are not open on Thanksgiving but take pie orders to be picked up either Tuesday or Wednesday before Thanksgiving.

Read More

Are they open now?

Theresa Buckner | Sep 16, 2017
Rob Hughes | Sep 16, 2017

Their web site has their hours listed... Go early!

Read More

Do you have a gluten free menu

Glenn Fullone | Sep 16, 2017
Vicki Meyer | Sep 16, 2017

It Amish cooking, other then salads and veggies, i dont know.

Read More

Do you make cinnamon rolls and sticky buns

Susan Jordan | Jul 17, 2022
Michael Jackson | Jul 17, 2022

Cream cheese cinnamon rolls

Read More

Do you have Pennsylvania style Baked Lima beans??

Daniel Desmond | Mar 19, 2022
Elmer Hickman | Mar 19, 2022

Usually Yoder's restaurants share Amish recipes.

Read More

Is the restaurant pet friendly, if you eat outsidw?

Nancy Cheatham | Mar 19, 2022
MARY HEWITT | Mar 19, 2022

No

Read More

Do you have lunch buffet?

Wayne Beaudoin | Mar 19, 2022
Jackie Florentino | Mar 19, 2022

No all to order plates

Read More

Do you serve meal buffet style or only orders from the menu?

Lucia Roney | Feb 17, 2022
Jan S. | Feb 17, 2022

Only from menu. But you sure will not be sorry you are there. Food & pies are wonderful. When I have to take my car down to Bradenton for service, I always go the extra 1/2 hour to Yoders. 10 Star's

Read More

Does Yoders ship apple butter out of state ?

Donna Taylor | Jan 18, 2022
Celinés “YeyaBond” Zayas | Jan 18, 2022

Need to go directly to their website or call them so U can ask them directly to THEM...

Read More

Do you have a Thanksgiving buffet and at what price

Russ Pearson | Dec 19, 2021
julie guy | Dec 19, 2021

No buffet, but turkey is a regular on the menu. For Thanksgiving you can order their whole pies up to 2 weeks in advance and just swing by and pick them up.

Read More

does Yoder have a buffet

David and Phyllis Gheen | Nov 19, 2021
Barb Eaton | Nov 19, 2021

No it's a dine in or pick up window

Read More

Do you have gift cards and would you mail them?

Nancy F. | Nov 19, 2021
julie guy | Dec 19, 2021

They have a gift shop with an assortment of everything from cards to gifts. I picked several, they were not Amish nor made by Yoder's the clerk said. They were still attractive and I will mail them.

Read More

Is this a buffet?

Jessica Tamayo | Oct 20, 2021
Jem Jender | Oct 20, 2021

No...

Read More

What time does the gift shop open from and which days .

Deborah Holsinger | Sep 15, 2021
Nicholas Wleklinski | Sep 15, 2021

Check their website

Read More

HOW CAN I GET YODERS SUGAR FREE EMON HARD C ANDY TO PORT CHARLOTTE FL

Helene | Sep 15, 2021
Curtiss Muschamp | Sep 15, 2021

Purchase it directly from the store or call and make arrangements for delivery

Is there parking at Yoders for a 40' motorhome?

Karen Amundson | Sep 15, 2021
Ben Guthrie | Sep 15, 2021

Looks like the question has been answered.

Read More

Does this place serve mimosas?

Melinda Thornberry | Sep 15, 2021
Diane Szarek | Sep 15, 2021

No

Read More

My wife has celiac disease so she has to eat gluten free. Can they support that? She's a trooper and will stick to salad for my sake, but I like to feed her something if the gluten free menu is super limuted

Jason cooley | Sep 15, 2021
Yvonne Grant | Sep 15, 2021

Yes, I did see some gluten free items. I just went to the market, deli, and the ice cream shop.

Read More

Is there outside seating available and may a small dog be there?

John Wiseman | Sep 15, 2021
xVgMgUPgjM4egr5PhLPxh | Sep 15, 2021

Yes there is 4 or 5 picnic tables there. As for your pet, there are no signs posted saying "no pets allowed". So, i guess it would be up to the others sitting in the area. If your pet is well behaved and not bothering others then I wouldn't see any issues. There are Amish family's that eat there (outside) regularly and I am unfamiliar with their customs and or how they might react to animals in the eating area. There was two full families dining when we stopped and ate outside. Very nice and friendly though, great peaceful relaxing enviroment to have a meal at.

Read More

Are you working with Uber Eats or any other delivery service to a location in Sarasota?

Angeline Sackett | Sep 15, 2021
charles west | Sep 15, 2021

Great food

Read More

Are they open Thanksgiving Day?

linda ruger | Sep 15, 2021
Donna Monroe | Sep 15, 2021

I would hope not. You need to call

Read More

Is the Restaurant open this Thanksgiving Day?

Tracey Fischell | Sep 15, 2021
Beth Patton | Sep 15, 2021

I think so as well

Read More

Are tables social distanced and are they any outside places to eat

Debbie Patterson | Sep 15, 2021
Paul Murray | Sep 15, 2021

Yes

Read More

Are they doing social distancing?

Gary Patterson | Sep 15, 2021
Beth Patton | Sep 15, 2021

Yes if waiting in line masks are there for distance you wear masks until seated.

Read More

Do you have outside dinning??

Lucille Arcuri | Sep 15, 2021
Donald Henderson | Sep 15, 2021

Yes , and you have the same service as inside .

Read More

do you have seat inside or is it take out??

Janice Merritt | Sep 15, 2020
T T55 | Sep 15, 2020

I ate inside. they seat you .mask requested outside while waiting in line to be seated.

Read More

How far is it from Sarasota National cemetary?

sarah flannigan | Sep 15, 2020
Sandor Horvath | Sep 15, 2020

15 20 min as you see

Read More

Do you sell Backroad Country Original Pork Rinds?

Janice Cothern | Sep 15, 2020
Kenneth Koehler | Sep 15, 2020

No

Are you open on New Year's day

Stacey Judkins | Sep 15, 2020
Jane Forrest | Sep 15, 2020

Not sure call them!!

Are you open tomorrow for orders..

andrea ducko | Sep 15, 2020
Brandon J | Sep 15, 2020

Call in the morning

Will you open on Christmas Day?

Marines Rivera | Sep 15, 2020
Kim Jenkins | Sep 15, 2020

Closed

Read More

Where is the nearest hotel

Eddie Evans | Sep 15, 2020
David Hollinger | Sep 15, 2020

The Carlisle Inn next to Der Dutchman restaurant, 1 block up.

Read More

Are you open today, Thanksgiving?

Ruth VanDerWege | Sep 15, 2020
Dale S | Sep 15, 2020

Closed on Thanksgiving

Read More

Do they serve beer or wine?

Joanne Pochowski | Sep 15, 2020
Sharon Worrell | Sep 15, 2020

No

Read More

What forms of payment do you accept??

Yasmin c: | Sep 15, 2020
Low Profile | Sep 15, 2020

Cash, credit and debit is all that I am aware of.

Read More

Do you sell scrapple

Chris Amato | Sep 15, 2020
Xplorer941 | Sep 15, 2020

Perhaps contacting Yoder's directly and asking might give you the quickest answer.

Read More

Do you ship to other states like North Carolina

Cathy Solomon | Sep 15, 2020
Dale S | Sep 15, 2020

I think they ship non-perishable items but not perishable items

Read More

Are you open on Sunday?

LauraLea Keays | Sep 15, 2020
lawnworks llc | Sep 15, 2020

Closed

Read More

Are you open Thanksgiving?? 2019

Janice Merritt | Sep 15, 2020
lawnworks llc | Sep 15, 2020

They have been before,call to find out.

Read More

Are you open sunday?

Pamela Collinsworth | Sep 16, 2019
Jay Brown | Sep 15, 2020

Closed on Sundays, just like Chick Fil A

Read More

Are you open for Thanksgiving Day supper 2019?

Rodney Perdomo | Sep 16, 2019
Dale S | Sep 16, 2019

Yes they're open regular hours Thanksgiving Day

I've noticed that the fresh peach pie as a lot of peach gel and less peaches then it used to. Why is that?

Elisabeth Celentano | Sep 16, 2019
cheron burton | Sep 16, 2019

Seems they changed the recipe looks like less fresh more processed peaches but still damn good

Read More

Is this a buffet

Debbie Firth | Sep 16, 2019
Dale S | Sep 16, 2019

No Buffet but the portions are huge you're usually take something back with you

Read More

Are your pies made with lard?

Sharon Smith | Sep 16, 2019
Dale S | Sep 16, 2019

I don't know but they're as good a pies as you're ever going to eat

Read More

Do you ship the breads and pies?

Alishia Maninger | Sep 16, 2019
Xplorer941 | Sep 16, 2019

They can be purchased for takeout, but don't expect a box arriving at your door with a coconut cream pie in it. Their baked goods do not have preservatives only natural ingredients they're best served fresh.

Read More

What is open and close

Florita Watson | Sep 16, 2019
Victoria Frame | Sep 16, 2019

6am-8pm Mon-Thu, 6am-9pm Fri-Sat, closed Sun

Read More

Do they have a vegan menu?

pakaibil | Sep 16, 2019
Nicole Hamm | Sep 16, 2019

No it is an authentic Amish Restaurant everything is made with butter & lard.

Read More

Are you open on Easter

Richard Petitta | Sep 16, 2019
Rocco Santomenno | Sep 16, 2019

They are closed every Sunday, if they are Amish.

Do you still your buffet at night what time start

Diane Bailey | Sep 16, 2019
Valerie Marshall | Sep 16, 2019

Not aware of an evening buffet

Read More

Do you take reservations

Charlene Rifelj | Sep 16, 2019
Stan | Sep 16, 2019

No

Read More

Are you open on Monday's?

Carol Dorman | Sep 16, 2019
Rose King | Sep 16, 2019

https://www.yodersrestaurant.com/ Yes check out their website

Read More

What time open on s,unday?

sandie farrell | Sep 16, 2019
Jamie Bell | Sep 16, 2019

They aren't open on Sunday that's the day of worship

Read More

When are you closing today?

William Tapia | Sep 16, 2019
Anthony Difulgo | Sep 16, 2019

Not sure you would have to call them

Read More

Open Christmas Day?

Claudette Chretien | Sep 16, 2019
Mike Auchter | Sep 16, 2019

Doubtful

Read More

Open on Christmas??? If not how late u open Christmas Eve?

Mike Million | Sep 16, 2019
Blake Cobb | Sep 16, 2019

Call, I don't know.

Do you hAve elbow spaghetti

Karen Shockley | Sep 16, 2019
Dominique Bassett | Sep 16, 2019

No, just regular spaghetti. You'll find it in the macaroni salad instead.

Are you open for Thanksgiving and do/have available reservations?

Jayleen Montgomery | Sep 16, 2019
Jack Ivins | Sep 16, 2019

No, closed on Thanksgiving

Do yoders have frash turkeys and how much a Lb.

A Google User | Sep 16, 2019
Tina Patterson | Sep 16, 2019

Yes i think they R on sale 1.99 a lb

When May I pick up my thanksgiving pies?

Ora Flannagan | Sep 16, 2019
Nelson Miller | Sep 16, 2019

The day before thanksgiving is when people normally pick up the pies they have on order.

will they be open Thanksgiving?

Ron R | Sep 16, 2019
Blake Cobb | Sep 16, 2019

not sure, call

Read More

Are they open thanksgiving

Deb Green | Sep 16, 2019
Patricia Woodall | Sep 16, 2019

No

do you sell mince pies?

Michael Carnell | Sep 16, 2019
John Sands | Sep 16, 2019

Yes

Open Thanksgiving day ?

Donna Cassin | Sep 16, 2019
Julie Flachner | Sep 16, 2019

No, they are not... sorry

Hours on Thanksgiving?

Carol Waddey | Sep 16, 2019
Richard Fiala | Sep 16, 2019

Sorry I don't even know if they are open for Thanksgiving.

What are your hours through Thanksgiving weekend

A Google User | Sep 16, 2019
Patricia Woodall | Sep 16, 2019

If you Google them it has the hours on their website.

Are they open Sundays

Ardath Hunter | Sep 16, 2019
John Sands | Sep 16, 2019

They are closed Sundays period

Read More

Do you take reservations or a 'call ahead' when leaving the house?

Rosemary Tierra | Sep 16, 2019
Douglas Robbins | Sep 16, 2019

Nope

Read More

Will you be open on Thanksgiving?

Becki Stoudt | Sep 16, 2019
Patricia Woodall | Sep 16, 2019

No

Read More

Do you have a thanksgiving dinner for thanksgiving

Linda Harvey | Sep 16, 2019
Anna McDaniel | Sep 16, 2019

I heard they have a huge feast for thanksgiving. An Linda was also right that you can get turkey with all the fixings an sides all year long!

Read More

Is Yoda opened on Columbus day

Robin Parker | Sep 16, 2019
C. Czoschke | Sep 16, 2019

Yes they are open. Blueberry pie is great.

Read More

Are you closed any day of the week.

kim vitko | Sep 16, 2018
Yvette Kimm | Sep 16, 2018

Sunday closed

Read More

Do they have a buffet?

Nancy Holmstrand | Sep 16, 2018
Eric Twachtman | Sep 16, 2018

Not that I encountered.

Read More

Do you take reservations?

Msdemeanor “Msdemeanor” Scott | Sep 16, 2018
Cammie Wolfe | Sep 16, 2018

No, they do not.

Read More

Does yoders take reservations?

bobby walton | Sep 16, 2018
Theresa Baschon | Sep 16, 2018

No

Read More

Can we bring a group of 15 to 20 people and get a place to sit together?

Teresa Kirk-Woods | Sep 16, 2018
Cammie Wolfe | Sep 16, 2018

Call and ask. They do have a couple if booth tables along the back wall that might work.

Read More

what are the breakfast hours?

Frances Nykamp | Sep 16, 2018
Jerry & Lorie “Woody” Widmann | Sep 16, 2018

Until 1100. They may do all day. Might want to call and see

Read More

Are their gluten free options on the dinner menu?

Dee “Dee” | Sep 16, 2018
Adam | Sep 16, 2018

I believe there is gluten free options, there menu is also on there website

Read More

Will you be open 4th of July?

Tracie Norton | Sep 16, 2018
Destiny Arcadi | Sep 16, 2018

They are open 6am-2pm for the 4th

Read More

Do you cook anything with Soy or Margarine? We are considering coming on Wednesday but have one person with this allergen and Peanut allergy

Tall Terri | Sep 16, 2018
Ron Williams | Sep 16, 2018

You could call ahead and ask them but I don't think they cook anything was peanut butter oil

Read More

do they have peach pie yet?

Jim Whalen | Sep 16, 2018
Ron Williams | Sep 16, 2018

I'm not sure but it is that time of the year for peach pies

Read More

Do they have alcohol??

elaine braun | Sep 16, 2018
Deborah Mendez | Sep 16, 2018

No

Read More

Will Yoders be open Memorial Day?

Ellen P. | Sep 16, 2018
Cynthia Carter | Sep 16, 2018

Not from Sarasota FL

Read More

Is Yoder closing?

Barbara Atkins | Sep 16, 2018
Bill Waller | Sep 16, 2018

Someday.

Read More

Are you open Mother's Day?

Betty Beach-Connell | Sep 16, 2018
Jeffrey Mckinney | Sep 16, 2018

Closed Sundays always they are real amish

Read More

Do they have a buffet?

Roger GreenLeaf | Sep 16, 2018
Douglas H | Sep 16, 2018

No buffet. Just good food.

Read More

Does Yoders have a buffet?

Fred Jasmund | Sep 16, 2018
Krista Starnes | Sep 16, 2018

No, but Der Dutchman does

Will u be open on easter

Halley Murray | Sep 16, 2018
Duane Spicer | Nov 19, 2021

Can i order a couple of pumpkin pies?

Read More

Are you serving corn beef & Cabbage. on St. Patrick's Day?

Jo Farnen | Sep 16, 2018
Janet Brubaker | Sep 16, 2018

No

Read More

Do you take reservations?

Richard Bishop | Sep 16, 2018
Alan Hanson | Sep 16, 2018

No reservations, but turnover is quick.

Read More

Do you ever have pepper cabbage on your menu?

Virginia Belviso | Sep 16, 2018
Krystal1999 | Sep 16, 2018

I don't think so unfortunately, but they do have many other delicious things on the menu! Try the country fried steak!

Read More

Do they have wifi

James Parrish | Sep 16, 2018
Pat Irwin | Sep 16, 2018

I don't know we was eating

Read More

Is breakfast served all day

Kim Buist | Sep 16, 2018
Treven & Brynja Phipps | Sep 16, 2018

No

will you be open new years day?

Joyce Hadley | Sep 16, 2018
Tim Fitch | Sep 16, 2018

Check website.

Read More

Are you open Christmas DAY?

Ed Storch | Sep 16, 2018
Terri Hartman | Sep 16, 2018

Not open Christmas Day. Owned by Amish so not open on any Sunday.

Read More

Are they open on Thanksgiving

Pam Weil | Sep 16, 2018
Lorenzo Sanchez | Sep 16, 2018

No

Read More

Do you have gooseberry pie and do you have fried morel mushrooms?

Craig Kizer | Sep 16, 2017
Brad Young | Sep 16, 2017

Craig, I suggest that you call Yoder's. I cannot remember if I saw those items on the menus. Sorry.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places