Nicky's Pizzeria

Ben

This pizza is really good. Folks here were nice. Felt compelled enough to come leave a review. I like the dough and thin crust. Crispy edges just right. Sauce has flavor, light spice, and isn’t overly sweet. Cheese is high quality and not too lean.

BootsyCat Meow

Today Friday May 6th 2022 I ordered A pizza 1/2 white with yellow peppers & extra cheese and 1/2 Pepperoni and extra cheese, and OMG!😋 IT IS SOOOOO GOOD. I HAD TO CALL AND EXPRESS MYSELF. THANK YOU FOR SUCH GOOD PIZZA and the delivery service on time. MmmmGood.

Andrew T

I thought I was well-versed in Youngstown pizza but just had this for the first time and can't believe what I've been missing! Every bite was loaded with a delicious proportion of sauce, toppings and cheese, and the flavors and ingredients were top notch. Cannot wait to come back next time I'm in town!

Deborah Larson

This is one of the BEST pizza places in our area!! Everything is fresh and homeade, including the sauce, dough, and sausage!! Family owned for 50 years! Highly recommend!