Frosty Frog

Terrie Theibert

I ate at the Frosty frog and the food is usually really good but tonight a young girl with a long braid waited on me at the window..I got pizza burger...it was terrible..it was grease soaked and looked like they cooked it in the deep fryer.Ive Been sick ever since I ate it and the bag was greased soaked too.Another thing that turned my stomach was that young girl waits on people at window and touches the dirty money then goes back and touches the buns etc without wearing gloves..I doubt if I will go back there.Not sure if same owners but food has gone down hill .

Katie Punchak

We have been going here for years. Their soft serve is the greatest. The cones are VERY fresh. Servings are generous. Prices great. People are friendly.

Judy Miller

Amazing! Huge servings... Price great!! Good thing I didn't order a large sunde!!

Elizabeth Peetz

We visit the Frosty Frog every time we’re in the Sandusky area. It is a hole in the wall located in the small town of Castalia. Everything is on the menu and you can’t go wrong. Staff is always so friendly. Wait times can get long as …