Paesano's

Lori Ravetto

I went to place an order for Father's day today and after being on hold, and repeatedly having the call disconected for 40 minutes in total no one ever picked up. Put an away message on if you're not there because it doesn't make sense that the phone can ring for 40 minutes with no one picking up. It's not like the line was busy its as if everyone working went home early for the day even though their hours of operations show open until 9pm. Very disappointing.

Jason Nadaskay

My first time here was just for a quick slice of pizza while on the go. I was pleasantly surprised with the pizza. Crispy bottom, doughy center, the sauce was perfect. Will definitely stop in again when in the area.

John Randall

I have lived in New Paltz, closer to Gardiner, for 8 years. All of this time I have been going to that other pizza place...you know the one right in "downtown" Gardiner. I somehow overlooked this place, which is only a couple of minutes farther away. Last night I got a large pizza from them for the first time and g*d help me it is as good as the best pizza places in NYC. So now I have to face the fact that I spent 8 years putting terrible pizza in my mouth hole when I could have been getting this AMAZING pizza that whole time. This makes me sad but also happy at the same time. Trust me on this, best pizza in the New Paltz area.

Tina Loveday

This place is a total joke. Its too bad because they actually have decent pizza. I have actually ordered a pie from them and they were closed when I went to pick it up. They do not stay open as stated on their website hours. When I …