Brother's Pizzeria

Brandon

My wife grew up on Staten Island. This is the first pizza place that she took me to when we were dating. I have yet to find better chicken rolls or plain pizza anywhere on the Island, Jersey, or heck, Manhattan! We live in Georgia, and if we drive up to visit family, we not only eat here during the trip, but we get food to take all the way back to GA. It's that amazing! Do yourself a favor, go to Brothers, get at least a chicken roll, and ASK FOR EXTRA SAUCE FOR DIPPING! I could drink the stuff! Remember, it's cash only, and they have an ATM at the front door. Enjoy your slice of heaven!

Mariya Bugay

Fried calamari was excellent, fresh and soft not rubbery. Pizza was good too. The service was friendly. I would recommend

opencorners

Best square pie on the island. Get extra sauce.

John

Back in the day this was one of the best spots for Pizza. Now a days it’s fell of considerably in My opinion. The Sicilian is still Pretty good. The regular pie is average at best.