Stemie's 1818 Tavern

Jed Marsh

Food (Buffalo chicken cheesesteak ' honestly not sure if I even had cheese in it', chicken club wrap, wings, and crab soup - soup was actually really good, only reason I'd go back if someone desired to go there) and the couple martinis we had were average to just above average (price wise) I've paid the same amount, roughly $12/ea., for better and worse. Nothing to write home about. Called Friday to have reservations for Saturday, apparently someone at the establishment messed up and we had to wait well over 30 minutes with a toddler, spoke with a manager and nothing was done to resolve the error on their part. Not even coming over to the table to apologize once again. Kind words go a long way to people who are completely understanding given such trying times. A genuine apology, or a free drink, or even a dessert for the table, go a long way. Otherwise the service, once we got to the table, was average /above average. Would have went 4 stars, being a foodie, and preferring to support local, I find it hard to review places liberally that can't atleast make even the smallest attempt to fix an error on their part.

Angelo Stambolis

Fantastic place. Food was great and the interior is a part of history. Had nachos grande and chicken fingers for appetizers. Topped it off with an English burger and my son had chicken wings. Great tavern food with the perfect atmosphere.

Tom Yerves

Great friendly service,great food. Awesome Sherry Crab bisque. Best burgers in the area. Excellent pub, Guinness on tap AND poured correctly. Wife is big fan of their 70+ Martinis.

Marty McGuire

Used to be the best crab cakes we ever had. No longer. Double crab cakes price increased from 28 to 47, and quality seems to have decreased.