Old Chicago

Nathan Choler

Came in for lunch while in Casper for a wedding. The group chose to come here for lunch. Our group was large, so I'll cut the server some slack, but the food came out and calzones weren't marked and we're given to the wrong people, it was quite the cluster and no apology was given. Besides that, the food was really good. Parking was ample and there was a lot of seating in the restaurant. Besides the mess up on delivering the food, we would come back here again.

Esther Johnson

I'm personally giving this place a 4.5/5 stars 🌟! I loved the bruschetta even though my S/O thought the bread should've been crisper (technically he was right but I still loved it). He tried the boneless wings and had a burger as his meal. The burger was cooked as it should be, and he said it was good but not necessarily something he would recommend to others. The boneless wings were also good. I had one of the specialty pizzas on the menu that had chicken and spinach. I ordered it thin crust which was definitely the way to go. I decided to take off the sun-dried tomatoes because I'm not a fan and added mushrooms instead which really complimented. All around a very good meal with prompt service!

Stan Campbell

I always have the same thing... the double bacon cheeseburger and it's always excellent. Cooked to perfection, the 1/3 pound Angus burger on a fresh and tasty hamburger bun is killer. Our server the last time I was there it was named Edil, I think. He was excellent. Extremely personable and efficient. He provided excellent customer service. Keep up the good work.

Matt F

This place was recommended while we were visiting. The service and selection was spot on. Would recommend sticking to pizza and the apple wings. Thank you all for the great experience.Matt, we love hearing our Casper restaurant took care of you and that you enjoyed our pizza & apple wings. Thank you for the 5 stars and see you again soon 👋