American Star Diner

Alden

The food, friends, and service were all great. I had a seafood trio, broccoli, sweet potatoes, and a lemonade. The fried flounder was very good

Matthew Lyons

We ate here for breakfast and everything was very good. Our favorite was the biscuits and gravy. It's a very popular place that was very busy when we were there. You can definitely spot a popular local place when there's this many people there.

Frank Costello

The past few times there, always a problem. Last night was the final straw, we will never go back. Ordered French onion soup, when it came out the soup was so hot the liquid was actually boiling. The melted cheese was 1 shade lighter than back. One sip and you could taste that the soup, cheese, onion & croutons were burnt. Sent it back. Order perogies topped with sauerkraut, was charged $2.00 for about 3 tablespoons of kraut. Was not told it would be an added charge. Wife ordered chicken croquettes, outside crust hard, dark brown. Very dry even with beef gravy. Served with beef gravy, not chicken gravy. Waitress never stopped by table to ask if we needed anything. They were not busy. Only 6 other customer in diner. Our last time there. Many diners out there. We all should be able to leave a business happy.

Mary Gehman

The new menu is scaled down and the prices went up a bit. The food is good. The service is pretty good too. HOWEVER …