Arcaro and Genell

Sergio Rosales

Great little place. For some reason indoor seating was close. The cashier was a bit hard to understand. Honestly had no clue what we where ordering. Ended up being a really good pizza.

J. Gray

We received the two pizzas as a "get well" gift. We had the cheese/rosemary one today (with left overs for tomorrow). Incredible! We have had good pizza (North End, Boston), but this taste and crust was over the top. Wish I could give it 10*. Big thanks to our generous friend, Jamie, for introducing us to a very different pizza.

Robert Drobish

First time but definitely not the last! We ordered takeaway tripe and several other dishes last night for a family party. The staff was amazing and very hospitable! The food was even better. Literally the best tripe we’ve ever tasted. We placed our order hoping that it would live up to the several other reviews we read, and they did not disappoint! We live about 35 minutes from this restaurant, and it is well worth the trip. You won’t be disappointed coming here for great food. Thank you to all the staff, and Happy New Year!

M B

Our favorite pizza place in Rehoboth Beach, DE (Casa DiLeo) has Old Forge Red pizza on the menu- which I always ordered as an add-on to our usual large pie. I finally got around to researching Old Forge and after reading an article about the "Pizza Capital of the World you never heard of", I knew I had to visit. Arcaro and Genell is located on a main street dotted with Italian restaurants and pizzerias. The whole town has a back-in-time feel and a family friendly atmosphere. When we arrived there was a women's bocce league playing in the adjoining covered courts and kids running everywhere. Due to the pandemic, there was no inside dining, so we ordered an original crust 12 cut tray with hot peppers and pepperoni plus an order of hot peppers stuffed with prosciutto and cheese and dined at one of their many covered outdoor tables. The pizza was amazing. While it has the looks of a Sicilian pie, the crust, sauce and cheese blend provide and very distinct flavor profile. I like pizza that I can taste the sauce and Arcaro and Genell's savory, rich sauce perfectly complements the crust and cheese proportions. If you are in the Poconos, definitely make the trip to Old Forge and try the pizza at Arcaro and Genell. If you are a pizza connoisseur- definitely stay a few days!