Tomato Pie Pizza Joint

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 100 W Union St, Paragon, IN 46166, USA

Phone: +17655379000

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–9PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 10:30AM–9PM

Wednesday: 10:30AM–9PM

Thursday: 10:30AM–9PM

Friday: 10:30AM–9PM

Saturday: 10:30AM–9PM

Reviews

Lisa Williams

Aug 4, 2022

All good things must end…..they have at Tomato Pie. Always loved this place and drove miles to get here..no more. I understand a price increase in today’s economy, although they were already on the high side, I was willing to pay for quality. As usual credit card machine not working, problem for well over a year now. No air conditioning, unprofessional help, pizza toppings are about 1/3 of what they used to be. Breadsticks were good but undercooked slightly, doughy in the middle. Salad was decent still. Not worth my trip out there any more.

Zalk in VR

Jun 16, 2022

It is truly one of if not the best pizza places I have been to in my life. It can't get much better than this. People would always tell me to go there but I have put it off, which was a gigantic mistake.

Eva Antonova

May 6, 2022

Moved to Paragon a while ago and quickly became a fan. Everything is very fresh, the staff is great and I swear there must be a block of cheese on every pizza. Ordered extra cheese and I never thought i would say that's a bit too much!

Floyd Foster

Oct 15, 2021

The service and food was excellent! I love their pizza sauce, I have acid reflux and it doesn't bother me. Their sauce is home made. The price was very reasonable especially for a small town family shop! I highly recommend trying this place out. I got a 12" Stromboli with meet cheese and sauce! As I write this review I long to return for another. I will definitely make it my goal to return, I live 15-20 miles away.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Can you tell me how to make your pizza sauce for dipping bread sticks? Pls?!!!!!

Pam Perry | Aug 11, 2018
John Stigall | Aug 12, 2018

From what I understand, the sauce is marinara, homemade, with olive oil added. So, take a jar of marinara, good quality, add tomato paste and some olive oil, simmer gently.

can you order online?

A Google User | Aug 11, 2018
Ricardo Sanchez | Aug 12, 2018

Indeed yes you can.

Read More

Is this place associated with Tomato pie pizza joint in California?

Joshua Prentice | Aug 10, 2020
Kevin Tinkle | Aug 11, 2020

I don't know for sure. My guess would be probably not

What forms of payment do you accept in addition to cash?

pj stierwalt | Aug 10, 2020
Julie Smith | Aug 11, 2020

We used our debit card.

Read More

What time do you open Sunday morning

Cindy Chastain | Aug 11, 2019
Chip Jackson | Aug 12, 2019

Tomato Pie opens at 11:00 AM EST on Sunday

What nutritional values of the breadsticks?

Paula Ratliff | Aug 11, 2018
Angelina Watt | Aug 12, 2018

None, but they are delicious!

Read More

Does this place deliver to Gosport?

GuessWho | Aug 11, 2018
Lisa Shelton | Aug 12, 2018

Artesian Menu only goes as far south as Tomato Pie itself. Unless they have changed since I checked. My address is Paragon and Artesian menu doesn't deliver to my house. Tomato Pie does not deliver.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places