Matthew's Pizzeria

Toya Harris

I haven’t gotten a Matthew‘s pizza for quite some time now. The only thing I recommend is there mozzarella pie no toppings. It is amazing. The cheese is always crispy and well done the crust is always well done and crunchy. It is the best pizza on the planet hands-down. But I do not recommend anything else on the menu. I wish I could bring my own drink because their fountain sodas are always flat. Highly recommend the pizza.

John

A must have when in or around Baltimore! Right on Eastern Avenue near the east corner of Patterson Park. Matthews has been in the community forever. They have many pizza options. From three cheese (my favorite), crab, Margareta, meat, and more. The traditional is a bit of a deep dish, but you can also order thin crust too. If it's your first time, definitely start with a traditional though. In addition to the pizza, they have pasta, subs, salad, etc. I really like their ranch dressing. If you're wondering what appetizer to start with, definitely try the meatballs! I love pizza. Have been coming to Matthews for years, and it has never disappointed.

Austin LeGeer

I have been coming here with family for years . The quality has never gone down if anything the food has only gotten better . The quality of service is amazing . The salad for a starter is a go to , the three cheese pizza with pepperoni, the meat lovers , and the margherita are always a hit, and dont forget to grab a cannoli for dessert.

Alan Jones

Oh My Goodness... This is THE PLACE TO GO! I had a good feeling about this place when I hit door. The first person I met was Julia who when I told her it was my first time there took her time to explain the menu to me. Ordered a large crab pie with diced shrimp, a large pizza with both cheeses... half pepperoni and mushroom... half sausage and onion. A salted Carmel chessecake and a Limoncello cake. The crab pie with diced shrimp was delicious... there sure was plenty of crab (and shrimp) on that pie. I'm the pepperoni and mushroom guy... that took me back... I wasn't sure if I was in NY or Philly... but I was in Highlandtown! I couldn't get enough of this pizza! Had to taste the salted Carmel Cheesecake and it was fantastic. That's going to go great with my coffee. Tasted the Lemoncello cake and that sent me to another planet it was so good. That will be perfect with my tea. Matthew's Pizza is all that and then some. They have been around for 79 years. I see why people rave about it... I'll be back!