Bay City Seafood Restaurant

KL Dean

Ordered and was massively disappointed. Crab stuffed mushrooms... just awful. 4 no bigger than a quarter mushy mushroom caps. Could not tell if the crab was frozen or canned. Lacked texture and had too much moisture to hold its own. The mushrooms themselves were just mushy. Definitely not worth the $12. Very sad Soft shell was way way over cooked...even the mustard was HARD. The best part... it was delivered and sat on another table before it was brought to ours. Grant you this is a nice area of York/Adams County but still... major serv safe violation. My plate was the crab melt... again... mushy but unlike the crunchy over cooked soft shell, this was room temperature on the inside. The pretzel roll was the star. Service was very slow. There wasn't much business this evening, but we walked in 45 minutes before closing. It took 35 minutes for the appetizer to get to the table. Floors were dirty. What was good... the mayo, friendly staff and blk and tan Yuengling.

Pierre Publico

Place needs to be updated, but the food and service was great. Really great place for seafood lovers and visitors of the area. A bit pricey, but overall justified for what you are given. Overall has a wonderful time, I suggest getting their specials of the day as it is served the freshest.

LilRed The Fam

Catch of the day. It was amazing taste. Filled me up no bad things at all. I would recommend it

Witty

Food was delicious, but overpriced for the portion size. (My plate was almost $30 and the main course was about the size of my fist. It was so good though, and I could have eaten twice that amount.) The fish was cooked to perfection. 👌 We came when it was very busy and it took an hour and 30 minutes from sitting down to receive our plates. We were there for almost a total of 3 hours! Service was attentive but slow, understandably. The outdoor dining was very pleasant. The kitchen was wonderful and the chef was willing to work with a food intolerance (we were told they could fry fish with just the breading and egg wash and skip the dairy). The waitress checked with the kitchen to see if any of the dishes we were interested in contained dairy. Wonderful service. Best sangria!!