Old Mill Restaurant

Category: Seafood restaurant in Evansville, Indiana

Address: 5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, IN 47720, USA

Phone: +18129636000

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–3PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: Closed

Thursday: Closed

Friday: 5–9PM

Saturday: 5–10PM

Reviews

Shinigami Mai

May 28, 2022

Just reopened food was good they have family style like loginn

Stephanie Mann

Oct 14, 2021

This place was so awesome! The owner was so friendly. Made us feel right at home. The food was delicious. I loved Sandy's dressing. She said it was her grandmother's recipe. If we're ever in Indiana again we will stop in and enjoy a delicious meal.

Paul Cron

Aug 22, 2021

The old Mill has fallen on hard times. The new owners are struggling to survive. Although the food is very good the staff and cleanliness I have suffered greatly. I only hope the new management can make a go of it.

Donald Hancock

Dec 6, 2020

The food was fresh, hot, and delicious. They've not been busy due to Covid. I stopped by last week on a whim. They were open. I talked to Sandy and said I would return with my family this week and boy did they deliver. They are open Fri-Sun. We had the buffet but they did it family style. Take that little 10-15 min trip to New Harmony Rd and give them a try.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Feb 7, 2021
Pete Semmel | Feb 8, 2021

Mask and social distancing

Are there Crab legs on sat night

Hanna Smith | Aug 6, 2020
John Strader | Aug 7, 2020

Not sure, its either friday night or saturday night they have all you can eat at a good price

Do they have all you can eat crab legs?

Court Mariah | Aug 7, 2019
Marc Hafele | Aug 8, 2019

Yes On The Weekend Buffet!

Read More

Reservations for mothers day lunch

Marybeth Rush | Aug 7, 2019
Marc Hafele | Aug 8, 2019

Yes They Take Them

What happened to food and service, close this place down

Marvin Buente | Aug 7, 2019
Krista Gardner | Aug 8, 2019

Call it in

Read More

are you open thanksgiving day? if so, what is the cost per adult?

Glenn McFadden | Aug 7, 2019
Tom Gregory | Aug 8, 2019

I would call them. It got crazy last year and they ran out of some serving items before the end of the day like gravy and stuffing.

Read More

Placed looked closed on a friday night at 6. Anyone know if they open anymore

Chad Wilkins | Dec 9, 2020
tony blue | Dec 10, 2020

It’s been on and off last few months.Not only Covid restrictions owner lost her son a couple months ago, then lost her husband of over 50 years Just weeks ago. Place is cleaned and ready. Won’t be around much longer. Try again! Open for Thanksgiving. Dine in,Curbside,and delivery service (must call ahead)

Read More

Is it a chain?

Mary Frerking | Aug 7, 2018
Thermal Tech | Aug 8, 2018

No it is not a chain, it is a very old place with good food. The weekend buffet with crab legs is what i recommend.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places