Caputo's Pizza Company

Brandon Morrison

I know a guy from Brooklyn who lives here now. Born an raised NY. Great guy. I ran into here when I was here on some business. He lives a town or 2 over. I asked him, "what brings you all the way out here to this place?" Now, before you say anything, I meant no disrespect to the joint. I just ate there. I was good. Really good. Had the lady at the counter pick me out her favorite and I devoured it. 1st time there...I bump into my friend, again, I'm there on business, never heard of the place, he says to me, he says, "I come here for the pizza!" I said "the pizza? You're from New York? Why come to Cherryville for Pizza?" He looks at me and he said, "This is the closest thing to NY style piza anyone near here. It's worth the trip every time" Now I know to get the pizza next time go.

Zachary Clary

Had a calzone. Delivered on wax paper that dissolved under it, unknown how much paper I ate. Plastic ware, so cutting it was not happening. The marinara sauce was so bad it tasted like the can was dissolved into the sauce. The waitress was wonderful.

Leslie Gosnell

Disappointed after reading all the great reviews! The garlic knots reminded me of the taste of pillsbury crescent rolls. The pizza crust was tough. ☹️

Leigh Green

I just ordered from here for the first time. We ordered pizza, wings and salad. I am quite fussy when it comes to wings. This was hands down the best wings I've ever had as takeout! The salad and pizza were great too! I am a new customer for life!