Mama Carolla's

Calton Zheng

The calamari was soo good and tender. Would recommend anyone to try Mama Carolla's. Loved the atmosphere as well. Very much enjoyed my experience tonight!

Jerry Foltz

This place has fantastic vibe and excellent food. The menu covers all the classics. The service was good and the prices were very reasonable. I'd highly recommend this place and I'll definitely be returning.

McKay Corbo

Yuck! Yuck! This place was so disappointing! Everyone’s rave reviews had us really excited to eat here! So we went for our anniversary dinner! And sadly so disappointed….my husband didn’t even finish his meal it was far too salty! But I did share my baked ziti which as you can see used 2 different kind of pasta in it…that is a first for me the smoother noodles were insanely over cooked and pretty mushy!! 🤢 I’m so sad our experience was so poor! Sadly I don’t think we will ever return! My advice is to check out diavola right down the street!

The Elevator and Airplane Finder

Mama Carolla’s, one of the more high end Italian restaurants in the Broad Ripple area of Indianapolis. I came last night to celebrate a family member’s birthday and here’s our experience written out: Pros: Yes, when you first look at the menu, you would think the prices are a little expensive. But there’s a different reason for that. And the end result is for sure worth it. Their portions are very large. I ordered the Chicken Parmesan and honestly it’s one of the best I’ve ever had. It was so incredibly tasty and cooked to perfection. I also got some cheese bread and calamari for an appetizer and all that was amazing too. Our waiter was also super friendly and attentive to us and always kept us refilled on drinks. The dining area has a nice, antique looking vibe which is nice too. Cons: Definitely no cons right now. 5 out of 5 for Mama Carolla’s.