Insomnia Cookies

Michael Cobbs

Ordered 5 hours ahead, which is probably good because the order arrived 2 hours late. Imagine if I'd ordered 20-30 minutes ahead like their claimed delivery time! I called the store multiple times and they repeatedly told me my order was leaving the store right then. The last time I called and pointed out it was nearly 2 hours late, the guy on the phone just said yeah. When I pointed out he'd told me an hour ago that it was leaving the store he just said yeah again. They clearly do not care about timelines or customer service at all.

Sarah Pickup

Alot of bad reviews, but I was a walk in customer, not delivery. I found this cookie shop while visiting stillwater and OMG! DIABETES. I could eat a boxful. Yummy, soft, warm, delishness....GET IN MY MOUTH. I went on a holiday weekend and they were out of a lot of their regular cookies but no matter, I gobbled up some outside my usual favs. They did NOT disappoint.

Bill Hensley

I'm not big on sweet stuff, but I eat it occasionally. The peanut butter cookies here are the best I've ever had. Lord, they are wonderful. IDK about the others, the five times I've been here over the last couple years it's been all about peanut butter. Maybe I'll get another kind next time.

Keith Guerrero

I've been to this location a couple of times. No matter what time you visit, the cookies are always hot and soft like they just came out of the oven. A cookie place with milk should be the standard but isn't in most places so to find tons of milk was awesome. This time I tried the pumpkin spice latte cookie and the peanut chip cookie, both were amazing. I will definitely return here when I'm in town.