Flatlanders Pizzeria

Monica Martin

Really delicious pizza. Everything is homemade and I mean everything. They also deliver to Edgerton and nobody else does. My only complaint is our toppings always slide right off. We've tried waiting to eat thinking it's too hot. Tried using a spatula. Just nothing works. So, maybe the crust is too thin to support the toppings or too much sauce or the dough might have been overstretched. I'm not sure. It's definitely not going to stop me because it's seriously good. Just wanted to mention it. Edit. We've had them a few times since and haven't had an issue with toppings sliding. We've also kept it at 2-3 toppings at the most. Delicious pizza.

Jason Camis

This is some seriously good pizza! You don’t often find this high quality in a small town, but it’s worth a drive if you are anywhere in the area. Not a huge place, but big flavors and a unique menu of Neapolitan style pizza. Other specials too and even breakfast on Sundays.

Titus Smith

We got used to fire oven and specialty pies while living in New England, so it was an amazing surprise to find such a great pizza place in Baldwin when we moved here. The cheese sticks are my favorite thing on the menu, but I honestly haven't had one bad thing yet. My favorite spot in town!

David Painter

There is pizza and there is wood oven pizza. Flatlanders is the way pizza is meant to be eaten. This isn't frozen or packaged dough with ketchup for their sauce like you get at the Hut or Dom's. Flatlanders dough is their own recipe and tossed fresh. Their ingredients and toppings are local (some from their own garden). How do I know? Ask the owners! They are there whipping it up right in front of you. Very friendly service and they like to talk about pizza with one and all. Delicious!! Worth the drive.