Tarry Tavern

Steven Ullmer

My brother and I came here to get a bite before a show at the Tarrytown Music Hall. A small place and crowded, but still cozy. We sat at the bar and ordered drinks and appetizers. Even though we didn't get full meals, we were treated top notch. The service was fast and the food was yummy. A bit pricey but if you want real good stuff in Tarrytown, gotta pay the piper. It was worth it.

Randall Evans

Ordered two vegetarian appetizers because all I noticed among the entrees was mac-and-cheese. I figured the appetizer as an entree would be a few dollars more, but it looked about the same size as the appetizer portion (which my spouse ordered) and they charged *double* for it. $32 for gnocchi?? I get that the pandemic was hard on local businesses but they got a PPP loan along with many others. A few dollars extra is one thing....

Mern

I don’t give my five stars easily. But what a gem of a restaurant is Tarry Tavern! The food is delicious, cooked from scratch, and with an emphasis on healthy. They have no trouble accommodating gluten-free as the way the food is prepared it’s gluten-free as is already. The Parmesan polenta which accompanied the braised short ribs was creamy and smoother than most mashed potatoes I’ve had with this kind of dish. We also had the mussels as an appetizer and the dish could have been a meal as the mussels were so plentiful. Everyone was friendly and accommodating. Service was excellent. Food was excellent. We can’t wait to come back and that’s the best thing to be said about a restaurant.

Rich H

Came here on a friend's recommendation that has visited this place a couple of times before. Wait was a little long, staff was friendly. Started with the calamari that was perfectly cooked and very tasty. Entree was the beef short rib that was fall apart and just perfect. Overall the meal was great and will definitely be back when in the area!