Carmella's Cafe

Category: American restaurant in New Hartford, New York

Address: 8530 Seneca Turnpike, New Hartford, NY 13413, USA

Phone: +13157973350

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–11PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 11AM–11PM

Wednesday: 11AM–11PM

Thursday: 11AM–11PM

Friday: 11AM–11PM

Saturday: 11AM–11PM

Reviews

David S

Jul 28, 2022

Excellent place (exception:see * below), and highly recommend this place, lot's of options, some nice daily specials, and 2 for 1 drinks is a real nice bonus. I had the tuna melt.. it was delish! *Well today that was a different story... seems like they forget to put the tuna on the whole sandwich. (See pic) I came back for seconds but this time my sandwich was not as good. Hate when that happens. Still try this place out! Plus after 8pm apps special is unheard of!

william defazio

Jul 26, 2022

Stopped in havent been there in a while. service was fast and friendly, food was very good and plenty of it, bringing home as much as I ate there.

Christopher Zawaly

Jul 13, 2022

When you walk in your greeted emediately. The surveys and staff are extremely friendly and helpful. The best part of the food was the appetizer. The main entre was some of the worst food I've ever had at a resteraunt. The Alfredo is far from creamy the broccoli is undercooked and entire heads in the Alfredo. Chicken parm is fried so much its black. And you can taste burnt hamburger in the lasagna. I'd only go again if I were making appetizers my meal. Very disipointed.

Chrissy F

Apr 4, 2022

Great service and delicious food! Love the atmosphere as well, the antiques are perfect!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Is there wine , beer or spirits served.?

Anne Cochrane | May 12, 2021
Carmella's Cafe (Owner) | May 13, 2021

Yes thank you Frank most are also two for one as well

Read More

What are meal choices for people who are doing keto?

Francis Lee | Jul 12, 2019
Fred Perra | Jul 13, 2019

I would contct the restaurant and present your question. They have always been accomodating.

Read More

is carmella's open for sunday brunch?

Jacqueline Pruskin | Jul 12, 2018
chuck baye | Jul 13, 2018

As far I remember yes they are open for Sunday brunch. And just talked with owner yes they are 9-12.

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Mar 13, 2021
Carmella's Cafe (Owner) | Mar 14, 2021

Very good!

Read More

What is your wait time between 11am & 1am on Satudays

Patricia Eckler | Mar 13, 2021
Lashawn Ferguson | Mar 14, 2021

0 wait time

When do they have steamed clams?

Roseanne Smith | Jul 12, 2019
Michael Ezzo | Jul 13, 2019

Every day $10.99 with a special on thurs with a 16 oz draft $13.99

Read More

Who does your landscaping! It always looks nice

carrie Cook | Jul 12, 2019
Carmella's Cafe (Owner) | Jul 13, 2019

Thank you! For over 15 years We have been with Cheryl and Peter Youngman of CP gardens 315 269 5229

How long would I have to wait to get a gift card during a busy period.

Keith Race | Jul 12, 2018
Jon | Jul 13, 2018

Vary quick

Read More

How many beers do you get for free with the buy one get one free special?

Ryan Titus | Jul 12, 2018
DR Colby | Jul 13, 2018

You buy 1, you get 1 free

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places