Don's Seafood Restaurant 1973

Sara Beachy

The staff was absolutely wonderful (five stars for that)! But the food, sadly, was not worth the over an hour wait… I’m fine with some fat trimming on my steak, but almost half of it was fatty and just not appetizing. I think our waitress noticed how unappetizing it was too as she only asked my husband if he wanted a box (which made us laugh). Everything else we had was pretty underwhelming too. Based on other reviews, the food seems like it could be hit or miss here. In my opinion, I would not want to come back to this restaurant again.

Josh

This is a great place to have a nice seafood dinner on the island. Our server was really kind and personable. The food here was really tasty and not expensive for the quality you got. They also have a ton of dessert options. I highly recommend this place. Parking can be challenging when they are busy. If you're within walking distance, which many of the islands hotels are, I'd recommend walking. This is my favorite place to eat on the island.

Karolyn Morgan

Good value home style seafood. Tasted great... service was great... parking was easy (right now in April on a week night) will be back

Manuel Miranda

We arrived just before opening and barely had to wait for seating. It filles up very quickly. Get there early unless you want to wait for 45 minutes. All the servers were courteous and attentive. I do have to say that the hostess (white red haired lady) wasn't as welcoming as the rest of the staff. Thankfully we didn't have to deal with after being seated. The food was soooo good. The stuffed shrimp are THE BOMB! The raw oysters seemed relatively fresh. Definitely can see why it's so busy. We went on a Saturday afternoon before Mother's Day 2021. Would definitely go again if in the area.