Cara Mia

Category: Italian restaurant in Seaford, New York

Address: 3935 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783, USA

Phone: +15168049280

Opening hours

Sunday: 2–9PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 12–9PM

Wednesday: 12–9PM

Thursday: 12–9PM

Friday: 12–10PM

Saturday: 2–10PM

Reviews

Alexandra Swayne

Jun 26, 2022

My mom threw my baby shower here yesterday and I’m so happy with how everything went! She couldn’t have chosen a better place. The restaurant is beautiful! It’s on the smaller side and has an intimate ambience to it. The food is delicious and the portion size is very generous. The staff were also so kind! Sergio and the rest of the staff were so accommodating and helpful with the set up of the event as well as throughout the entirety of the party. Would highly recommend this place for hosting a party or even just for a meal out!

Infoodwetrustny Anthony M

May 28, 2022

Delicious food many choices and amazing quick service. The cavatelli & burrata spicy vodka sauce pasta was the best I have ever had.

Steve Mcpherson

Feb 15, 2022

I made a reservation for Valentines Day 3 weeks in advance for 7pm….I received a call at around 6pm on Valentines Day asking if I can come at 730 pm because they were backed up. When we arrived at 730 we were immediately seated. The problem was we were seated at a makeshift high top table between the bar and bathroom secluded and cramped away from regular seating . Our waitress was the bartender. She was nice and I did complain that I had made this reservation well in advance and this tiny high top bar table wasn’t acceptable. She explained that this table was used for reservations as well…Nothing was done and I had to make the best of it . I grew up in Queens Village and was a steady customer most of my life so I was excited to try their restaurant . This disappointing experience on such a special day being our first Valentine’s Day married was not what I planned ..Needless to say I won’t be going back

Raven Helfrich

Jan 5, 2022

Ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, and pet me tell you these have been the juiciest, most delicious meatballs I've ever had from any restaurants around me. Loved the kick of pepper in them. They are reasonably priced because I think from this dish alone they gotta be one of many best restaurants on the island. Keep it up.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Are you open on Thanksgiving

Lily Wegner | Jul 8, 2020
Lisa S | Jul 9, 2020

I am not sure, give them a call

Read More

Do they offer vegan choices?

Hector Miranda | Jul 9, 2018
J. Jotabug | Jul 10, 2018

It's a matter of make your own - by omission. There is a salad that is Vegan. You can order pasta Marina, no meatball. Also pasta with oil, garlic and broccoli rabe, no sausage.There is a great iced lemon - not on the menu.

Read More

Are they open mondays

Barbara Ruvin | Jul 9, 2018
J. Jotabug | Jul 10, 2018

Not open on Mondays

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places