New York Pizzeria

Melissa Carswell

I drive a semi truck often have a hard time to grab food. I was able to street park for a moment just to run in and grab a to go pizza. I don't eat cheese so they were able to make me a pizza with no cheese all veggies. It was great, however I didn't realize until after I received it there was no red sauce. It was a white pizza. Since I ordered by phone and did not see a menu I accepted these things happen. The pizza was good but I wish I had gotten to taste the red sauce as I'm sure it was good too. The restaurant looked authentic and fresh at the same time. The service was wonderful on phone and in person. I recommend this place for sure.

Clint Nicoll

One of the Best pizza restaurants in all of Chenango County! Great service and even better food. We love this place. Very family friendly oriented pizzeria 👌👌

Shane Rogers

THIS IS CENTRAL NEW YORK'S BEST KEPT SECRET! What a gem. We were actually going somewhere else that was closed due to the power outage and decided to try it. This is a local hot spot for sure. It's small (only about a dozen or so tables) but does a HUGE amount of business. There were loads of people picking up takeout food. We had set out for a sit-down dinner, so we didn't try the pizza but loads of happy customers did while we were there. For some reason there were no servers working, but we were welcome to sit in the dining room and eat. Our food came out in to-go containers and plastic cutlery. We ordered the Shrimp Alfredo and Chicken Saltimbocca. Our meals were amazing! Out of this world! With drinks our bill came to $40. The staff handled the huge crowd like pros. Very polite, very quick, and very competent. The restrooms were clean. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to a friend.

Char Herd-Shallenberger

A Sicilian treasure in upstate New York! ❤ I would travel there just to see Frank, and eat at his amazing restaurant! Be sure to leave room for a canoli, or take one to go! Friendly staff, delicious food, generous portions, reasonable prices, and a clean bathroom. ☺