Benny's Pizzeria

Will Baker

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE. We called to order at 7:02. Ordered an appetizer special, and a pizza wirh all pepperoni, half ricotta and meatball. Didn’t think this would be that complicated. Well I guess it was since our pizza didn’t get delivered until 8:49!! We live 8 minutes from bennys… Ok so finally we get our food and it’s cold!! Had to microwave the appetizer and put pizza in the oven. Then, one of the mozerlla sticks didn’t have cheese in it!! Also, the pizza only had 2 slices of just pepperoni when the entire half was meant to. If you’re going to take almost 2 hours one would think the order would at least be correct! And at only 8 minutes from the store, why is it cold?! If I could give negative 5 stars I would. 0/10 will not go again.

Beth A. Rose

I know the cost of food has risen but charging $25.00 for a large pepperoni pizza is a bit much. The pizza is good but not that good for $25.00.

Emilia DeCicco-Buono

Omg this pizza was perfect and Benny is such a great Guy. Stop in or order a delivery you’ll love it !

Irene Shafer

Best pizza I've ever had! The crust was absolutely perfect - crispy and chewy at the same time, the kind of crust you do leave on the plate. The toppings were plentiful and tasty - I got the BBQ chicken and it was amazing. My friend and I were just passing by on our way back from Kingston, looking for someplace with outside seating to grab a quick bite. The inviting garden was the perfect setting - and the food was just awesome. Great prices, too!