Manny's Pizza

Christian Foster

Went for slices here. Visited on a weekday and there weren't many slices. Wish there was more options. I got a meat lovers and a grandma slice. They were both great but the grandma slice takes the cake. 8.8 / 10. Great flavor and creamy texture. Has notes of garlic and some basil sprinkled on it. Every bite was great. The slices were really big too. In retrospect, I think a plain slice would've been better than the meat lovers. It adds a lot of grease with the meat. It was good but could be better. I'd give meat lovers a 6.

Sultryzulu's Music

I’ve lived in neighboring Essex County for nearly 20 years and had no idea Manny’s was here. The reviewer who said this was hands down the best Italian food (including and especially, garlic knots) for miles around? told no lies. At our usual place, the phone went unanswered for rings and rings and rings. In one of the reviews of our usual place, Manny’s (now, our extraordinary place) was mentioned. We had nothing to lose. I had some wonderful piece of business known as a drunken chicken sub. The kid had baked ziti. *Chef’s Kiss* lol. I forgot to ask for extra sauce on the side but when I went to pick it up, was accommodated with no problem. In fact they had to check if it was available because the sauce goes first and fast (and with good reason). This is gonna sound like I’ve thought too much about it but bear with me, then trust me, the sauces (we had vodka on the sub and red in/on the ziti) were perfectly balanced ratios of tangy, sweet, savory, salty and herb-y. We were back again two days later. If I can figure out internet, next time I go, I’ll ask Manny to star in my tik tok.

Andy B

Awesome food. The pizza was nice and crispy. Incredible tasting and a joy talking to the guys there. Best pizza in the area. Definitely going back again and again!!! 👍😁

Kevin Brown

Maybe the best slice I've ever had. Crispy, Cheesy and Full of Flavor to the LAST BITE! Super friendly staff. They even put on some kids tv for my LO. Easy Repeat