Muscarella's Cafe Italia

TJ Joseph

What a terrific experience! Our family of 5 visited to celebrate a birthday and we were thrilled. The atmosphere is beautiful and festive (and I truly appreciate that there are no TV's distracting our family meal!!!). Our waitress Sydney was kind, quick and efficient. And the food was delicious- huge portions and very fairly priced. But my favorite part was the attention to children. The kids' menu was much larger than other restaurants and my boys LOVED drawing on the table covering. We had a very enjoyable, relaxed and delicious experience from start to finish!

Gary H

Muscarella's has it all! Atmosphere, a fantastic menu and great food! We found out about Muscarella's via word of mouth from a stranger in a dept. store when asking about a good restaurant to go to for a wedding anniversary. We were surprised to get a recommendation for a restaurant that is 40 miles away from us in Sharpsville Pa. We made the trip on a Thursday evening arriving at 6pm and had to wait about 10 minutes for a table to be ready as they were all occupied. Tip... when we left at 7 pm, about 1/3 of the tables were available so arriving a little after 6 might get you in with less or no waiting. My wife had the Muscarella's Pasta Trio and I had the Sirloin Tips & Asiago Gnocchi. Both meals were outstanding! The Sirloin tips were super tender and cooked to perfection. The Pasta trio was delicious! We also had a cup of Wedding soup along with our meals, try it you will like it. So.... Did we like Muscarella's? Absolutely! It is on the top of our favorite Restaurant list!

Janet Sobnosky

Very nice older restaurant with nice ambiance... really like it has allot of private booths with high backs to keep your dining private. Food was delicious... compliments to the chef tonight!!! They were very busy had a party upstairs and small one in the back but we never waited more than a few minutes for anything... all staff worked so well together as a team

Gordon Shaffer

Popular, local Italian restaurant that serves up huge portions of delicious pasta and toppings. Two of us ordered the seafood linguine fully packed w shelled mussels & clams, scallops & shrimp in a white sauce. Very good! My wife had pappardelle pasta w brazed short rib ragu. It was delicious! I can't forget the large House and Caesar salads beforehand. Plan on taking home plenty of leftovers.